{ "id": "email-marketing", "title": "邮件营销", "question": "Best email marketing for a small business with 2000 opted-in contacts and 4 monthly campaigns?", "candidates": [ "MailerLite", "Brevo", "Mailchimp" ], "audience": "已有 2000 名许可订阅者的小企业，每月 4 次群发（约 8000 封），另行区分交易邮件。", "scenarios": [ "简单 newsletter 与欢迎流程", "较大名单但低发送频率", "需要更多营销集成与分群" ], "criteria": [ "联系人与发送量计费", "欢迎流程与分群", "编辑门槛", "集成与导出", "费用包含项" ], "special_prompt": "prompts/categories/email-marketing.md", "url": "https://bestforwhat.com/best-for-email-marketing/", "article": { "category_id": "email-marketing", "intro": "做 newsletter 和欢迎序列，可以先看 MailerLite；名单大但发送少，比较 Brevo 的发送量计费；需要电商行为分群和多步旅程，再看 Mailchimp。", "workload": "基础场景：2,000 名订阅者、每月 4 次群发，加 100 名新订阅者的两封欢迎邮件，共约 8,200 封。另比较 5,000 人低频群发。", "entries": [ { "product": "MailerLite", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "best_for": "newsletter、欢迎序列及基础分群。", "rationale": "Mailercloud 描述了 MailerLite 的欢迎序列、条件分支和自定义字段筛选，可以先用两封欢迎邮件验证搭建与维护是否顺手。", "caveat": "先确认当前套餐能覆盖 2,000 人同日群发和每月 8,200 封；不要直接套用旧免费额度或旧套餐价格。", "status": "先核实额度", "evidence_strength": "limited", "evidence": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-welcome" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-branch" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-segment-fields" } ], "source_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "source_id": "s20", "url": "https://www.mailercloud.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp", "title": "MailerLite vs Mailchimp (2026): 14-Round Comparison", "publisher": "Mailercloud" } ] }, { "product": "Brevo", "candidate_id": "brevo", "best_for": "联系人较多、发送频率较低，想比较发送量计费的团队。", "rationale": "MailerLite 描述了 Brevo 按发送量计费的方式。低频发送时值得单独算一遍，但还要同时看联系人容量。", "caveat": "免费档每日 300 封的限制无法覆盖同日 2,000 人群发。选择付费档时，把联系人上限、日发送量和自动化范围一起确认。", "status": "先算实际工作量", "evidence_strength": "limited", "evidence": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c1" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c2" } ], "source_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "source_id": "s1", "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/brevo-alternative", "title": "MailerLite vs Brevo", "publisher": "MailerLite" } ] }, { "product": "Mailchimp", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "best_for": "需要电商行为触发、多步分支和更细分群的营销流程。", "rationale": "Mailercloud 描述了 Mailchimp 的多步分支、行为触发和自定义字段组合分群，适合先搭一个实际客户旅程验证。", "caveat": "自动化能力随套餐变化；联系人账单还可能包含退订和非订阅联系人。先整理名单，再确认流程档位和发送额度。", "status": "先核实自动化档位", "evidence_strength": "limited", "evidence": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c3" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c4" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-behavior-triggers" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-segment-fields" } ], "source_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "source_id": "s2", "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/mailchimp-alternative", "title": "MailerLite vs Mailchimp", "publisher": "MailerLite" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "source_id": "s20", "url": "https://www.mailercloud.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp", "title": "MailerLite vs Mailchimp (2026): 14-Round Comparison", "publisher": "Mailercloud" } ] } ], "prompt_version": "2.0.0", "edition": "v2-2026-09-28", "updated_at": "2026-09-28", "status": "partial", "hands_on_testing": false }, "runs": [ { "id": "codex", "metadata": { "model_id": "gpt-6-astra", "model_display_name": "GPT-6 Astra", "prompt_version": "2.0.0", "hands_on_testing": false }, "review_status": "original-with-host-annotations; consult integration", "research": { "schema_version": "2.0.0", "category_id": "email-marketing", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "status": "partial", "metadata": { "model_id": "gpt-6-astra", "reasoning_effort": "high", "started_at": "2026-09-27T23:16:52.790325+00:00", "completed_at": "2026-09-28T00:11:30.719257+00:00", "cutoff_at": "2026-09-27T23:16:52.790325+00:00", "input_sha256": "384bfc67b04bce886d7c5a2c19f9dc10c13f8c1731ccede99f13338e584c6331", "plan_sha256": "3e23853e394c518ea0df6b797dbedf581611720c658032362453515b1088dbbf", "tool_environment": "Codex web.search_query / open / find；查询结果和读取响应在私有日志保存。首批查询时间为近似记录；results 未逐条转录，不表示搜索无结果。", "source_policy": "competitor-only", "hands_on_testing": false }, "plan": { "audience": "已有 2000 名许可订阅者的小企业，每月 4 次群发（约 8000 封），另行区分交易邮件。", "assumptions": [ { "id": "reference-market", "statement": "面向中文读者的英文界面软件比较；以美国可用服务、USD软件报价为参考，不假定中国大陆可用性。", "decision_impact": "其他地区、币种或语言需另行核实，不直接外推。" }, { "id": "cost-unknown", "statement": "未给定硬性预算；只比较明确支持的计费结构，不强行选最便宜。", "decision_impact": "成本缺项不填零，不能宣称性价比冠军。" }, { "id": "non-sensitive", "statement": "参照场景为非敏感数据与获同意的测试用途，不代表可以直接处理客户敏感数据。", "decision_impact": "隐私、录制法律与合规保证仍需独立核实。" } ], "candidates": [ { "id": "mailerlite", "name": "MailerLite", "inclusion_reason": "延续首版种子候选，非全市场抽样。" }, { "id": "brevo", "name": "Brevo", "inclusion_reason": "延续首版种子候选，非全市场抽样。" }, { "id": "mailchimp", "name": "Mailchimp", "inclusion_reason": "延续首版种子候选，非全市场抽样。" } ], "scenarios": [ { "id": "newsletter", "task": "2000名许可订阅者每月4次群发加两步欢迎流程", "workload": { "opted_in_contacts": 2000, "campaigns_per_month": 4, "campaign_sends_per_month": 8000, "recipients_per_campaign": 2000, "campaign_delivery_window_days": 1, "new_subscribers_per_month": 100, "welcome_steps": 2, "automation_sends_additional": 200, "transactional_email": false }, "must_have": [ { "id": "newsletter-automation", "requirement": "支持两步顺序欢迎自动化", "why_required": "单封欢迎不能替代两步流程", "requires_independent_verification": false }, { "id": "newsletter-send", "requirement": "可行套餐支持一次2000人群发及月8200封总量", "why_required": "月额度不能掩盖日限", "requires_independent_verification": false } ], "preferences": [ { "id": "newsletter-billing", "criterion": "联系人账单口径", "priority": 1, "observable_question": "退订、重复和归档如何计费？" }, { "id": "newsletter-editor", "criterion": "编辑与管理工作流", "priority": 2, "observable_question": "对手评价有没有具体操作依据？" } ], "reversal_conditions": [ "若任一硬约束无法满足，取消候选资格；若决定性依据过时或范围不符，先核实。", "预算、地区、数据敏感程度或现有工具改变时重新判断。" ] }, { "id": "low-frequency", "task": "保留5000联系人，每月仅发送一次群发", "workload": { "opted_in_contacts": 5000, "campaigns_per_month": 1, "campaign_sends_per_month": 5000, "campaign_delivery_window_days": 1, "automation": false, "transactional_email": false }, "must_have": [ { "id": "low-list", "requirement": "可行套餐允许保存5000联系人", "why_required": "要保留完整许可名单", "requires_independent_verification": false }, { "id": "low-send", "requirement": "可在一个发送日内向5000人群发", "why_required": "不以月总额度推断峰值可行", "requires_independent_verification": false } ], "preferences": [ { "id": "low-structure", "criterion": "低频发送的计费结构", "priority": 1, "observable_question": "按联系人还是发送量计费？最低额度是什么？" }, { "id": "low-exit", "criterion": "抑制列表与导出迁移", "priority": 2, "observable_question": "退订状态能否保留？" } ], "reversal_conditions": [ "若任一硬约束无法满足，取消候选资格；若决定性依据过时或范围不符，先核实。", "预算、地区、数据敏感程度或现有工具改变时重新判断。" ] }, { "id": "segmentation", "task": "基于订阅属性与行为进行分群和分支自动化", "workload": { "opted_in_contacts": 2000, "campaign_sends_per_month": 8000, "automation_sends_additional": 1000, "branch_conditions": [ "subscriber attribute", "click event" ], "required_export": "contacts and suppression state", "transactional_email": false }, "must_have": [ { "id": "segment-rules", "requirement": "支持按联系人属性进行分群", "why_required": "需要有意义的人群拆分", "requires_independent_verification": false }, { "id": "segment-branches", "requirement": "支持行为触发的分支自动化", "why_required": "顺序欢迎流程不足以完成任务", "requires_independent_verification": false } ], "preferences": [ { "id": "segment-tier", "criterion": "高级自动化套餐门槛", "priority": 1, "observable_question": "分群与分支是否在同一档位？" }, { "id": "segment-data", "criterion": "集成和导出边界", "priority": 2, "observable_question": "只确认有依据的具体动作，未指定连接器不排名集成数。" } ], "reversal_conditions": [ "若任一硬约束无法满足，取消候选资格；若决定性依据过时或范围不符，先核实。", "预算、地区、数据敏感程度或现有工具改变时重新判断。" ] } ], "expected_unknowns": [ "竞争对手材料无法独立证明实际性能、合规和安全保证。", "精确场景成本、附加项与最新额度可能因严格来源政策而无法核算。" ], "search_budget": { "max_queries": 24, "max_url_read_attempts": 20 }, "frozen_at": "2026-09-27T23:16:52.790325+00:00" }, "plan_amendments": [], "search_log": [ { "id": "q1", "query": "Brevo MailerLite Mailchimp contacts automation daily limit comparison", "searched_at": null, "tool": "web.search_query", "locale": null, "results": [], "candidate_ids": [ "mailerlite", "brevo", "mailchimp" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "purpose": "discovery", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [] }, { "id": "q2", "query": "site.moosend.com MailerLite Mailchimp segmentation automation contacts limitations", "searched_at": "2026-09-28T00:06:09.697Z", "tool": "web.search_query", "locale": null, "results": [], "candidate_ids": [ "mailerlite", "brevo", "mailchimp" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "purpose": "counterevidence", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [] }, { "id": "q3", "query": "MailerLite Mailchimp alternatives", "searched_at": "2026-09-28T00:06:28.316Z", "tool": "web.search_query", "locale": null, "results": [], "candidate_ids": [ "mailerlite", "brevo", "mailchimp" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "purpose": "capability", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [] }, { "id": "q4", "query": "MailerLite alternatives", "searched_at": "2026-09-28T00:06:42.855Z", "tool": "web.search_query", "locale": null, "results": [], "candidate_ids": [ "mailerlite", "brevo", "mailchimp" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "purpose": "counterevidence", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [] } ], "sources": [ { "id": "s1", "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/brevo-alternative", "title": "MailerLite vs Brevo", "publisher": "MailerLite", "publisher_product": "MailerLite", "owner": "MailerLite", "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/brevo-alternative", "observation": "厂商品牌域名、产品导航及站内竞争产品比较；未进行独立公司股权尽调。" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "brevo", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "MailerLite 在本类别销售可替代软件；该段评价其他厂商候选。", "incentive": "争取竞争产品用户" } ], "evidence_family": "family-mailerlite", "family_reason": "按发布者归为同一信息家族；上游是否来自被评价厂商未独立确定。", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": null, "updated_at": null, "effective_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-09-27T23:24:22.375Z", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "已读取相关段落；未实测产品。", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": "工具读取记录私有保留；未生成逐来源全文快照。", "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s2", "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/mailchimp-alternative", "title": "MailerLite vs Mailchimp", "publisher": "MailerLite", "publisher_product": "MailerLite", "owner": "MailerLite", "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/mailchimp-alternative", "observation": "厂商品牌域名、产品导航及站内竞争产品比较；未进行独立公司股权尽调。" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "mailchimp", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "MailerLite 在本类别销售可替代软件；该段评价其他厂商候选。", "incentive": "争取竞争产品用户" } ], "evidence_family": "family-mailerlite", "family_reason": "按发布者归为同一信息家族；上游是否来自被评价厂商未独立确定。", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": null, "updated_at": null, "effective_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-09-28T00:06:47.125Z", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "已读取相关段落；未实测产品。", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": "工具读取记录私有保留；未生成逐来源全文快照。", "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s3", "url": "https://www.brevo.com/blog/best-email-marketing-services/", "title": "Best email marketing services", "publisher": "Brevo", "publisher_product": "Brevo", "owner": "Brevo", "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.brevo.com/blog/best-email-marketing-services/", "observation": "厂商品牌域名、产品导航及站内竞争产品比较；未进行独立公司股权尽调。" } ], "relations": [], "evidence_family": "family-brevo", "family_reason": "按发布者归为同一信息家族；上游是否来自被评价厂商未独立确定。", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": null, "updated_at": null, "effective_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-09-27T23:24:22.377Z", "access_status": "partial", "access_note": "只读到 iframe，未取得文章正文。", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": "工具读取记录私有保留；未生成逐来源全文快照。", "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s4", "url": "https://moosend.com/blog/mailerlite-review/", "title": "MailerLite review", "publisher": "Moosend", "publisher_product": "Moosend", "owner": "Constant Contact", "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://moosend.com/blog/mailerlite-review/", "observation": "厂商品牌域名、产品导航及站内竞争产品比较；未进行独立公司股权尽调。" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "Moosend 在本类别销售可替代软件；该段评价其他厂商候选。", "incentive": "争取竞争产品用户" } ], "evidence_family": "family-moosend", "family_reason": "按发布者归为同一信息家族；上游是否来自被评价厂商未独立确定。", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": null, "updated_at": "2023-05-30", "effective_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-09-28T00:07:08.995Z", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "已读取相关段落；未实测产品。", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": "工具读取记录私有保留；未生成逐来源全文快照。", "status": "unavailable" } } ], "claims": [ { "id": "c1", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "daily-cap", "claim_type": "quota", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "restatement", "reported_observation": "Brevo 免费档每日发送上限为 300 封。", "interpretation": "按该说法无法完成一次 2000 人或 5000 人同日群发；付费方案需另核实。", "scope": { "product_variant": null, "deployment": null, "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": null }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s1", "locator": "Pricing table / Free plan", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Brevo 免费档每日发送上限为 300 封。", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "竞争厂商以自己的名义描述对手，已读对应段落；不包含其自荐部分。" } ], "limitations": [ "未独立验证产品能力；套餐、地区或信息生效日期未完整确认。", "上游可能来自目标厂商资料，最多作为有限线索。" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "利益相关来源，信息上游与范围存在缺口。" }, { "id": "c2", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "send-based", "claim_type": "pricing_structure", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "restatement", "reported_observation": "Brevo 以发送量作为计费维度，并存在联系人额度。", "interpretation": "低频发送需要同时核对名单容量，不直接认定最便宜。", "scope": { "product_variant": null, "deployment": null, "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": null }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s1", "locator": "Pricing comparison / method and contacts", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Brevo 以发送量作为计费维度，并存在联系人额度。", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "竞争厂商以自己的名义描述对手，已读对应段落；不包含其自荐部分。" } ], "limitations": [ "未独立验证产品能力；套餐、地区或信息生效日期未完整确认。", "上游可能来自目标厂商资料，最多作为有限线索。" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "利益相关来源，信息上游与范围存在缺口。" }, { "id": "c3", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "billable-contacts", "claim_type": "pricing_structure", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "restatement", "reported_observation": "Mailchimp 将订阅、退订和非订阅联系人计入联系人账单。", "interpretation": "整理名单状态后再估算费用。", "scope": { "product_variant": null, "deployment": null, "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": null }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s2", "locator": "Pricing table / counting subscribers", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Mailchimp 将订阅、退订和非订阅联系人计入联系人账单。", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "竞争厂商以自己的名义描述对手，已读对应段落；不包含其自荐部分。" } ], "limitations": [ "未独立验证产品能力；套餐、地区或信息生效日期未完整确认。", "上游可能来自目标厂商资料，最多作为有限线索。" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "利益相关来源，信息上游与范围存在缺口。" }, { "id": "c4", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "standard-volume", "claim_type": "quota", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "restatement", "reported_observation": "Mailchimp Standard 的月发送量为联系人额度的 12 倍。", "interpretation": "没有确认单日限额及两步欢迎自动化，不能据此通过整个场景。", "scope": { "product_variant": null, "deployment": null, "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": null }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s2", "locator": "Pricing table / monthly sends", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Mailchimp Standard 的月发送量为联系人额度的 12 倍。", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "竞争厂商以自己的名义描述对手，已读对应段落；不包含其自荐部分。" } ], "limitations": [ "未独立验证产品能力；套餐、地区或信息生效日期未完整确认。", "上游可能来自目标厂商资料，最多作为有限线索。" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "利益相关来源，信息上游与范围存在缺口。" }, { "id": "c5", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "historic-segments", "claim_type": "capability", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "restatement", "reported_observation": "Moosend 在 2023 年的评测描述按地区和自定义字段分群。", "interpretation": "页面标题虽标 2026，正文明确资料截至 2023；不据此确认当前套餐。", "scope": { "product_variant": null, "deployment": null, "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": "2023-05-30" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s4", "locator": "Segmentation and personalization", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Moosend 在 2023 年的评测描述按地区和自定义字段分群。", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "out_of_scope", "reason": "资料明确截至 2023，不能证明 2026 当前状态。" } ], "limitations": [ "未独立验证产品能力；套餐、地区或信息生效日期未完整确认。", "上游可能来自目标厂商资料，最多作为有限线索。" ], "evidence_strength": "unusable", "strength_reason": "旧资料不支持当前判断。" } ], "constraint_matrix": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-automation", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-send", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-automation", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-send", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-automation", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-send", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-list", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-send", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-list", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-send", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-list", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-send", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-rules", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-branches", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-rules", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-branches", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-rules", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-branches", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "所读材料未完整支持该具体要求，不能从产品定位或集成名单推断通过。" } ], "preference_assessments": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-billing", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-editor", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-billing", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-editor", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-billing", "status": "supported", "claim_ids": [ "c3" ], "explanation": "有计费或维护线索，仍不支持相对排名。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-editor", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-structure", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-exit", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-structure", "status": "supported", "claim_ids": [ "c2" ], "explanation": "有计费或维护线索，仍不支持相对排名。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-exit", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-structure", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-exit", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-tier", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-data", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-tier", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-data", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-tier", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-data", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。" } ], "cost_comparisons": [ { "scenario_id": "newsletter", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "status": "incomplete", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": null, "commitment": null, "plan": null, "workload": { "opted_in_contacts": 2000, "campaigns_per_month": 4, "campaign_sends_per_month": 8000, "recipients_per_campaign": 2000, "campaign_delivery_window_days": 1, "new_subscribers_per_month": 100, "welcome_steps": 2, "automation_sends_additional": 200, "transactional_email": false }, "inputs": [], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "完整套餐和额度", "计费联系人/席位/动作口径", "必要附加项及税费" ], "excluded_costs": [ "实施、迁移及维护人工" ], "caveat": "不使用广告起价推算场景总价。" }, { "scenario_id": "newsletter", "candidate_id": "brevo", "status": "incomplete", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": null, "commitment": null, "plan": null, "workload": { "opted_in_contacts": 2000, "campaigns_per_month": 4, "campaign_sends_per_month": 8000, "recipients_per_campaign": 2000, "campaign_delivery_window_days": 1, "new_subscribers_per_month": 100, "welcome_steps": 2, "automation_sends_additional": 200, "transactional_email": false }, "inputs": [], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "完整套餐和额度", "计费联系人/席位/动作口径", "必要附加项及税费" ], "excluded_costs": [ "实施、迁移及维护人工" ], "caveat": "不使用广告起价推算场景总价。" }, { "scenario_id": "newsletter", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "status": "incomplete", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": null, "commitment": null, "plan": null, "workload": { "opted_in_contacts": 2000, "campaigns_per_month": 4, "campaign_sends_per_month": 8000, "recipients_per_campaign": 2000, "campaign_delivery_window_days": 1, "new_subscribers_per_month": 100, "welcome_steps": 2, "automation_sends_additional": 200, "transactional_email": false }, "inputs": [], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "完整套餐和额度", "计费联系人/席位/动作口径", "必要附加项及税费" ], "excluded_costs": [ "实施、迁移及维护人工" ], "caveat": "不使用广告起价推算场景总价。" }, { "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "status": "incomplete", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": null, "commitment": null, "plan": null, "workload": { "opted_in_contacts": 5000, "campaigns_per_month": 1, "campaign_sends_per_month": 5000, "campaign_delivery_window_days": 1, "automation": false, "transactional_email": false }, "inputs": [], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "完整套餐和额度", "计费联系人/席位/动作口径", "必要附加项及税费" ], "excluded_costs": [ "实施、迁移及维护人工" ], "caveat": "不使用广告起价推算场景总价。" }, { "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "candidate_id": "brevo", "status": "incomplete", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": null, "commitment": null, "plan": null, "workload": { "opted_in_contacts": 5000, "campaigns_per_month": 1, "campaign_sends_per_month": 5000, "campaign_delivery_window_days": 1, "automation": false, "transactional_email": false }, "inputs": [], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "完整套餐和额度", "计费联系人/席位/动作口径", "必要附加项及税费" ], "excluded_costs": [ "实施、迁移及维护人工" ], "caveat": "不使用广告起价推算场景总价。" }, { "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "status": "incomplete", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": null, "commitment": null, "plan": null, "workload": { "opted_in_contacts": 5000, "campaigns_per_month": 1, "campaign_sends_per_month": 5000, "campaign_delivery_window_days": 1, "automation": false, "transactional_email": false }, "inputs": [], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "完整套餐和额度", "计费联系人/席位/动作口径", "必要附加项及税费" ], "excluded_costs": [ "实施、迁移及维护人工" ], "caveat": "不使用广告起价推算场景总价。" }, { "scenario_id": "segmentation", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "status": "incomplete", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": null, "commitment": null, "plan": null, "workload": { "opted_in_contacts": 2000, "campaign_sends_per_month": 8000, "automation_sends_additional": 1000, "branch_conditions": [ "subscriber attribute", "click event" ], "required_export": "contacts and suppression state", "transactional_email": false }, "inputs": [], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "完整套餐和额度", "计费联系人/席位/动作口径", "必要附加项及税费" ], "excluded_costs": [ "实施、迁移及维护人工" ], "caveat": "不使用广告起价推算场景总价。" }, { "scenario_id": "segmentation", "candidate_id": "brevo", "status": "incomplete", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": null, "commitment": null, "plan": null, "workload": { "opted_in_contacts": 2000, "campaign_sends_per_month": 8000, "automation_sends_additional": 1000, "branch_conditions": [ "subscriber attribute", "click event" ], "required_export": "contacts and suppression state", "transactional_email": false }, "inputs": [], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "完整套餐和额度", "计费联系人/席位/动作口径", "必要附加项及税费" ], "excluded_costs": [ "实施、迁移及维护人工" ], "caveat": "不使用广告起价推算场景总价。" }, { "scenario_id": "segmentation", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "status": "incomplete", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": null, "commitment": null, "plan": null, "workload": { "opted_in_contacts": 2000, "campaign_sends_per_month": 8000, "automation_sends_additional": 1000, "branch_conditions": [ "subscriber attribute", "click event" ], "required_export": "contacts and suppression state", "transactional_email": false }, "inputs": [], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "完整套餐和额度", "计费联系人/席位/动作口径", "必要附加项及税费" ], "excluded_costs": [ "实施、迁移及维护人工" ], "caveat": "不使用广告起价推算场景总价。" } ], "conflicts": [], "scenario_decisions": [ { "scenario_id": "newsletter", "disposition": "investigate_first", "candidate_outcomes": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "disposition": "insufficient_evidence", "claim_ids": [], "gap_ids": [ "g-mailerlite-newsletter" ], "reason": "缺少当前适用的准入材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "disposition": "investigate_first", "claim_ids": [ "c1", "c2" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-brevo-newsletter" ], "reason": "有线索但缺少完整场景依据。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "disposition": "investigate_first", "claim_ids": [ "c3", "c4" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-mailchimp-newsletter" ], "reason": "有线索但缺少完整场景依据。" } ], "comparative": { "status": "insufficient_basis", "preferred_candidate_id": null, "comparison_claim_ids": [], "reason": "三者在相同任务量与决定性偏好上缺少可比证据，不设置赢家。" }, "options": [], "abstention_reason": "缺少完整硬约束或成本证据，先核实具体功能。", "verification_plan": [ { "question": "2000名许可订阅者每月4次群发加两步欢迎流程", "method": "用获同意的非敏感样例，按场景逐项操作必需功能并记录套餐、额度和失败状态。", "success_criterion": "所有必需功能在目标套餐和工作量下完成，关键输出完整且可追溯。", "status": "not_executed" } ] }, { "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "disposition": "investigate_first", "candidate_outcomes": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "disposition": "insufficient_evidence", "claim_ids": [], "gap_ids": [ "g-mailerlite-low-frequency" ], "reason": "缺少当前适用的准入材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "disposition": "investigate_first", "claim_ids": [ "c1", "c2" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-brevo-low-frequency" ], "reason": "有线索但缺少完整场景依据。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "disposition": "investigate_first", "claim_ids": [ "c3", "c4" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-mailchimp-low-frequency" ], "reason": "有线索但缺少完整场景依据。" } ], "comparative": { "status": "insufficient_basis", "preferred_candidate_id": null, "comparison_claim_ids": [], "reason": "三者在相同任务量与决定性偏好上缺少可比证据，不设置赢家。" }, "options": [], "abstention_reason": "缺少完整硬约束或成本证据，先核实具体功能。", "verification_plan": [ { "question": "保留5000联系人，每月仅发送一次群发", "method": "用获同意的非敏感样例，按场景逐项操作必需功能并记录套餐、额度和失败状态。", "success_criterion": "所有必需功能在目标套餐和工作量下完成，关键输出完整且可追溯。", "status": "not_executed" } ] }, { "scenario_id": "segmentation", "disposition": "investigate_first", "candidate_outcomes": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "disposition": "insufficient_evidence", "claim_ids": [], "gap_ids": [ "g-mailerlite-segmentation" ], "reason": "缺少当前适用的准入材料。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "disposition": "investigate_first", "claim_ids": [ "c1", "c2" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-brevo-segmentation" ], "reason": "有线索但缺少完整场景依据。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "disposition": "investigate_first", "claim_ids": [ "c3", "c4" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-mailchimp-segmentation" ], "reason": "有线索但缺少完整场景依据。" } ], "comparative": { "status": "insufficient_basis", "preferred_candidate_id": null, "comparison_claim_ids": [], "reason": "三者在相同任务量与决定性偏好上缺少可比证据，不设置赢家。" }, "options": [], "abstention_reason": "缺少完整硬约束或成本证据，先核实具体功能。", "verification_plan": [ { "question": "基于订阅属性与行为进行分群和分支自动化", "method": "用获同意的非敏感样例，按场景逐项操作必需功能并记录套餐、额度和失败状态。", "success_criterion": "所有必需功能在目标套餐和工作量下完成，关键输出完整且可追溯。", "status": "not_executed" } ] } ], "coverage_matrix": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "eligible_family_ids": [], "supported_constraints": [], "unknown_constraints": [ "newsletter-automation", "newsletter-send" ], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q2", "q4" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-mailerlite-newsletter" ] }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "eligible_family_ids": [ "family-mailerlite" ], "supported_constraints": [], "unknown_constraints": [ "newsletter-automation", "newsletter-send" ], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q2", "q4" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-brevo-newsletter" ] }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "eligible_family_ids": [ "family-mailerlite" ], "supported_constraints": [], "unknown_constraints": [ "newsletter-automation", "newsletter-send" ], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q2", "q4" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-mailchimp-newsletter" ] }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "eligible_family_ids": [], "supported_constraints": [], "unknown_constraints": [ "low-list", "low-send" ], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q2", "q4" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-mailerlite-low-frequency" ] }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "eligible_family_ids": [ "family-mailerlite" ], "supported_constraints": [], "unknown_constraints": [ "low-list", "low-send" ], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q2", "q4" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-brevo-low-frequency" ] }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "eligible_family_ids": [ "family-mailerlite" ], "supported_constraints": [], "unknown_constraints": [ "low-list", "low-send" ], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q2", "q4" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-mailchimp-low-frequency" ] }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "eligible_family_ids": [], "supported_constraints": [], "unknown_constraints": [ "segment-rules", "segment-branches" ], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q2", "q4" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-mailerlite-segmentation" ] }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "eligible_family_ids": [ "family-mailerlite" ], "supported_constraints": [], "unknown_constraints": [ "segment-rules", "segment-branches" ], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q2", "q4" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-brevo-segmentation" ] }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "eligible_family_ids": [ "family-mailerlite" ], "supported_constraints": [], "unknown_constraints": [ "segment-rules", "segment-branches" ], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q2", "q4" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-mailchimp-segmentation" ] } ], "excluded": [ { "source_id": "s1", "target_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "locator": "发布者自有产品介绍、营销优势与未经独立核实的质量保证段落", "reason": "不使用自荐、无法读出的表格符号或敏感质量保证。", "effect_on_decision": "不补齐候选硬约束，不据此排名。" }, { "source_id": "s2", "target_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "locator": "发布者自有产品介绍、营销优势与未经独立核实的质量保证段落", "reason": "不使用自荐、无法读出的表格符号或敏感质量保证。", "effect_on_decision": "不补齐候选硬约束，不据此排名。" } ], "coverage_gaps": [ { "id": "g-mailerlite-newsletter", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "question": "核实 支持两步顺序欢迎自动化；可行套餐支持一次2000人群发及月8200封总量", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。" }, { "id": "g-brevo-newsletter", "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "question": "核实 支持两步顺序欢迎自动化；可行套餐支持一次2000人群发及月8200封总量", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。" }, { "id": "g-mailchimp-newsletter", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "question": "核实 支持两步顺序欢迎自动化；可行套餐支持一次2000人群发及月8200封总量", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。" }, { "id": "g-mailerlite-low-frequency", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "question": "核实 可行套餐允许保存5000联系人；可在一个发送日内向5000人群发", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。" }, { "id": "g-brevo-low-frequency", "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "question": "核实 可行套餐允许保存5000联系人；可在一个发送日内向5000人群发", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。" }, { "id": "g-mailchimp-low-frequency", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "question": "核实 可行套餐允许保存5000联系人；可在一个发送日内向5000人群发", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。" }, { "id": "g-mailerlite-segmentation", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "question": "核实 支持按联系人属性进行分群；支持行为触发的分支自动化", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。" }, { "id": "g-brevo-segmentation", "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "question": "核实 支持按联系人属性进行分群；支持行为触发的分支自动化", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。" }, { "id": "g-mailchimp-segmentation", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "question": "核实 支持按联系人属性进行分群；支持行为触发的分支自动化", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。" } ], "future_candidates": [], "completion": { "queries_used": 4, "url_read_attempts": 4, "stop_reason": "完成有界的首轮来源扫描并保存独立结果；具体场景仍有决定性缺口，按 partial 交付，未宣称穷尽材料。", "unfinished_tasks": [ "部分要求缺少精确动作、套餐或当前有效日期的证据", "尚未进行产品试用或场景成本核算", "搜索结果排序与逐条未打开 URL 未转录到结构化表；实际工具响应保存在私有日志" ], "checks": [ { "check": "source-policy", "outcome": "pass", "note": "只将已读竞品评价作为有限依据；自荐及过时资料不支持当前约束。" }, { "check": "full-scenario-coverage", "outcome": "not_assessable", "note": "全部候选列入矩阵，缺证保留 unknown。" } ] } } }, { "id": "claude", "metadata": { "model_id": "claude-opus-5-5", "model_display_name": "Claude Opus 5.5", "prompt_version": "2.0.0", "hands_on_testing": false }, "review_status": "original-with-host-annotations; consult integration", "research": { "schema_version": "2.0.0", "category_id": "email-marketing", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "status": "partial", "metadata": { "model_id": "claude-opus-5-5", "reasoning_effort": "high", "started_at": "2026-09-28T00:24:13.822Z", "completed_at": "2026-09-28T00:40:50.963Z", "cutoff_at": "2026-09-27T23:16:52.790325+00:00", "input_sha256": "818700bb485c207445e3eb109b0894f59d4f43bee9ae88925ff740fa63cc5720", "plan_sha256": "3e23853e394c518ea0df6b797dbedf581611720c658032362453515b1088dbbf", "tool_environment": "WebSearch + WebFetch（Claude Agent SDK）。WebFetch 返回的是由小模型对页面转换后的 markdown 所做的提取/转述，不是原始 HTML 或逐字全文；因此本次运行无法保证摘录逐字准确，short_original_excerpt 一律置 null。", "source_policy": "competitor-only", "hands_on_testing": false }, "plan": { "audience": "已有 2000 名许可订阅者的小企业，每月 4 次群发（约 8000 封），另行区分交易邮件。", "assumptions": [ { "id": "reference-market", "statement": "面向中文读者的英文界面软件比较；以美国可用服务、USD软件报价为参考，不假定中国大陆可用性。", "decision_impact": "其他地区、币种或语言需另行核实，不直接外推。" }, { "id": "cost-unknown", "statement": "未给定硬性预算；只比较明确支持的计费结构，不强行选最便宜。", "decision_impact": "成本缺项不填零，不能宣称性价比冠军。" }, { "id": "non-sensitive", "statement": "参照场景为非敏感数据与获同意的测试用途，不代表可以直接处理客户敏感数据。", "decision_impact": "隐私、录制法律与合规保证仍需独立核实。" } ], "candidates": [ { "id": "mailerlite", "name": "MailerLite", "inclusion_reason": "延续首版种子候选，非全市场抽样。" }, { "id": "brevo", "name": "Brevo", "inclusion_reason": "延续首版种子候选，非全市场抽样。" }, { "id": "mailchimp", "name": "Mailchimp", "inclusion_reason": "延续首版种子候选，非全市场抽样。" } ], "scenarios": [ { "id": "newsletter", "task": "2000名许可订阅者每月4次群发加两步欢迎流程", "workload": { "opted_in_contacts": 2000, "campaigns_per_month": 4, "campaign_sends_per_month": 8000, "recipients_per_campaign": 2000, "campaign_delivery_window_days": 1, "new_subscribers_per_month": 100, "welcome_steps": 2, "automation_sends_additional": 200, "transactional_email": false }, "must_have": [ { "id": "newsletter-automation", "requirement": "支持两步顺序欢迎自动化", "why_required": "单封欢迎不能替代两步流程", "requires_independent_verification": false }, { "id": "newsletter-send", "requirement": "可行套餐支持一次2000人群发及月8200封总量", "why_required": "月额度不能掩盖日限", "requires_independent_verification": false } ], "preferences": [ { "id": "newsletter-billing", "criterion": "联系人账单口径", "priority": 1, "observable_question": "退订、重复和归档如何计费？" }, { "id": "newsletter-editor", "criterion": "编辑与管理工作流", "priority": 2, "observable_question": "对手评价有没有具体操作依据？" } ], "reversal_conditions": [ "若任一硬约束无法满足，取消候选资格；若决定性依据过时或范围不符，先核实。", "预算、地区、数据敏感程度或现有工具改变时重新判断。" ] }, { "id": "low-frequency", "task": "保留5000联系人，每月仅发送一次群发", "workload": { "opted_in_contacts": 5000, "campaigns_per_month": 1, "campaign_sends_per_month": 5000, "campaign_delivery_window_days": 1, "automation": false, "transactional_email": false }, "must_have": [ { "id": "low-list", "requirement": "可行套餐允许保存5000联系人", "why_required": "要保留完整许可名单", "requires_independent_verification": false }, { "id": "low-send", "requirement": "可在一个发送日内向5000人群发", "why_required": "不以月总额度推断峰值可行", "requires_independent_verification": false } ], "preferences": [ { "id": "low-structure", "criterion": "低频发送的计费结构", "priority": 1, "observable_question": "按联系人还是发送量计费？最低额度是什么？" }, { "id": "low-exit", "criterion": "抑制列表与导出迁移", "priority": 2, "observable_question": "退订状态能否保留？" } ], "reversal_conditions": [ "若任一硬约束无法满足，取消候选资格；若决定性依据过时或范围不符，先核实。", "预算、地区、数据敏感程度或现有工具改变时重新判断。" ] }, { "id": "segmentation", "task": "基于订阅属性与行为进行分群和分支自动化", "workload": { "opted_in_contacts": 2000, "campaign_sends_per_month": 8000, "automation_sends_additional": 1000, "branch_conditions": [ "subscriber attribute", "click event" ], "required_export": "contacts and suppression state", "transactional_email": false }, "must_have": [ { "id": "segment-rules", "requirement": "支持按联系人属性进行分群", "why_required": "需要有意义的人群拆分", "requires_independent_verification": false }, { "id": "segment-branches", "requirement": "支持行为触发的分支自动化", "why_required": "顺序欢迎流程不足以完成任务", "requires_independent_verification": false } ], "preferences": [ { "id": "segment-tier", "criterion": "高级自动化套餐门槛", "priority": 1, "observable_question": "分群与分支是否在同一档位？" }, { "id": "segment-data", "criterion": "集成和导出边界", "priority": 2, "observable_question": "只确认有依据的具体动作，未指定连接器不排名集成数。" } ], "reversal_conditions": [ "若任一硬约束无法满足，取消候选资格；若决定性依据过时或范围不符，先核实。", "预算、地区、数据敏感程度或现有工具改变时重新判断。" ] } ], "expected_unknowns": [ "竞争对手材料无法独立证明实际性能、合规和安全保证。", "精确场景成本、附加项与最新额度可能因严格来源政策而无法核算。" ], "search_budget": { "max_queries": 24, "max_url_read_attempts": 20 }, "frozen_at": "2026-09-27T23:16:52.790325+00:00" }, "plan_amendments": [], "search_log": [ { "id": "q01", "query": "MailerLite vs Mailchimp comparison", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://moosend.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://mailchimp.com/resources/mailchimp-vs-mailerlite/", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://www.mailercloud.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://www.emailtooltester.com/en/blog/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "独立测评/联盟站，仅发现用途，不准入" }, { "url": "https://www.emailvendorselection.com/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "独立测评/联盟站，不准入" }, { "url": "https://zapier.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "Zapier 为集成平台，非邮件营销竞品" }, { "url": "https://technologyadvice.com/blog/information-technology/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "独立媒体，不准入" }, { "url": "https://www.emailsoftwareinsights.com/compare/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "测评站，归属未明" }, { "url": "https://www.techradar.com/versus/mailchimp-vs-mailerlite", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "独立媒体，不准入" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "mailerlite", "mailchimp" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "purpose": "discovery", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [ "https://moosend.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp/", "https://mailchimp.com/resources/mailchimp-vs-mailerlite/", "https://www.mailercloud.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp" ] }, { "id": "q02", "query": "Brevo vs Mailchimp comparison pricing contacts", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://mailchimp.com/resources/mailchimp-vs-brevo/", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://www.mailercloud.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://moosend.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://lovable.dev/guides/10-mailchimp-alternatives-cost-less", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "发布者非邮件营销竞品" }, { "url": "https://www.emailtooltester.com/en/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "独立测评/联盟站，不准入" }, { "url": "https://www.layer3labs.io/comparisons/brevo-vs-mailchimp", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://www.sequenzy.com/versus/mailchimp-vs-brevo", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "可能为竞品，但读取预算优先给已确认竞品" }, { "url": "https://www.emailsoftwareinsights.com/compare/brevo-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "测评站，归属未明" }, { "url": "https://konabayev.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "个人博客，不准入" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "brevo", "mailchimp" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency" ], "purpose": "discovery", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [ "https://mailchimp.com/resources/mailchimp-vs-brevo/", "https://www.mailercloud.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp", "https://moosend.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp/" ] }, { "id": "q03", "query": "brevo.com Mailchimp alternative comparison page", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://www.brevo.com/blog/mailchimp-alternatives/", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://www.emailtooltester.com/en/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "独立测评，不准入" }, { "url": "https://moosend.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "已在 q02 发现并读取" }, { "url": "https://www.emailtooltester.com/en/blog/best-brevo-alternatives/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "独立测评，不准入" }, { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://mailchimp.com/resources/mailchimp-vs-brevo/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "已读取" }, { "url": "https://www.sequenzy.com/versus/mailchimp-vs-brevo", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.emailsoftwareinsights.com/compare/brevo-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://alternativeto.net/software/sendinblue", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "社区聚合，不准入" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "brevo", "mailchimp" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "purpose": "discovery", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [ "https://www.brevo.com/blog/mailchimp-alternatives/", "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp/" ] }, { "id": "q04", "query": "mailerlite.com compare MailerLite vs Brevo Sendinblue", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://www.joinsecret.com/compare/mailerlite-vs-sendinblue", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "聚合/优惠站，不准入" }, { "url": "https://www.emailtooltester.com/en/blog/best-brevo-alternatives/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "独立测评，不准入" }, { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailerlite/", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://inboxreads.co/tools/sendinblue/vs/mailerlite", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目录站，不准入" }, { "url": "https://inboxreads.co/tools/mailerlite/vs/sendinblue", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目录站，不准入" }, { "url": "https://www.emailsoftwareinsights.com/compare/brevo-vs-mailerlite/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://www.oreateai.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-sendinblue-finding-your-email-marketing-sweet-spot/b1c1ec6c7cdb8898cfe0bfee561ea54e", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "内容农场，不准入" }, { "url": "https://lite14.net/blog/2026/05/05/mailerlite-vs-sendinblue-which-tool-is-better-for-small-business-email-marketing/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://www.g2.com/compare/mailerlite-vs-sendinblue", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "评论聚合，不准入" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "mailerlite", "brevo" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "purpose": "discovery", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [ "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailerlite/" ] }, { "id": "q05", "query": "Brevo \"vs Mailchimp\" site:brevo.com", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://www.brevo.com/mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://www.brevo.com/blog/mailchimp-alternatives/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "已尝试读取（q03）" }, { "url": "https://www.brevo.com/blog/brevo-alternatives/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "主要为 Brevo 自身定位，预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.brevo.com/blog/mandrill-alternatives/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "交易邮件，超出场景" }, { "url": "https://www.brevo.com/integrations/mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "迁移营销页，预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.brevo.com/blog/best-email-marketing-services/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.brevo.com/blog/cheap-email-marketing/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.brevo.com/blog/mailchimp-prices/", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://www.brevo.com/blog/what-is-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "Brevo 页面此前两次读取均失败，预算优先" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "mailchimp", "brevo" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency" ], "purpose": "discovery", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [ "https://www.brevo.com/mailchimp/", "https://www.brevo.com/blog/mailchimp-prices/" ] }, { "id": "q06", "query": "MailerLite Mailchimp alternative site:mailerlite.com", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/mailchimp-alternative", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/blog/mailchimp-alternatives", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://mailerlite.com/madmimi-alternative", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "非本期候选" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/compare", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "标题显示 2023 年，可能过期" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/activecampaign-alternative?ml_campaignid=369860228&ml_adsetid=1177578762292597&msclkid=%7Bmsclkid%7D", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "非本期候选" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/brevo-alternative", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/kit-alternative", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "非本期候选" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/mailerlite-for-nonprofits", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "自荐页" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/blog/best-email-marketing-service-platforms", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "mailchimp", "brevo" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency" ], "purpose": "discovery", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [ "https://www.mailerlite.com/mailchimp-alternative", "https://www.mailerlite.com/brevo-alternative" ] }, { "id": "q07", "query": "Brevo pricing 2026 contact limit Starter plan daily sending limit removed paid plans", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://www.emailvendorselection.com/brevo-pricing/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "联盟测评站，不准入" }, { "url": "https://moosend.com/blog/brevo-pricing/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先给 2026 年页面" }, { "url": "https://www.emailtooltester.com/en/reviews/brevo/pricing/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "独立测评，不准入" }, { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-pricing/", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://www.fastlancer.org/en/fastlancer-blog/brevo-review/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://help.brevo.com/hc/en-us/articles/208589409-About-Brevo-s-pricing-plans", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述，不能作为产品事实证据" }, { "url": "https://mailsoftly.com/blog/brevo-pricing/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.emailsoftwareinsights.com/reviews/brevo/pricing/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://www.techradar.com/pro/software-services/brevo-review", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "独立媒体，不准入" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "brevo" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency" ], "purpose": "counterevidence", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [ "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-pricing/" ] }, { "id": "q08", "query": "MailerLite automation conditional split link clicked Growing Business plan vs Mailchimp Essentials 4 step journey", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/ultimate-guide-to-email-marketing/automation", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/blog/ab-split-testing-for-automation", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://backstageincome.com/blog/mailerlite-aweber-insidebsi-1/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "个人博客" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/blog/what-are-automation-triggers-and-how-you-can-use-them", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/features/automation", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/help/how-to-use-automation-steps", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/help/how-to-set-up-automation-triggers", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://mattgiaro.com/mailerlite-review/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "个人测评/可能联盟" }, { "url": "https://onlinetoolguides.com/mailerlite-advanced-automation-tutorial/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://mailchimp.com/help/about-customer-journeys/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://www.activepieces.com/blog/mailchimp-email-automation", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "集成平台，非竞品" }, { "url": "https://mailchimp.com/features/automations/customer-journey-builder/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://automationatlas.io/answers/how-to-automate-email-sequences-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://mailchimp.com/developer/marketing/api/customer-journeys-journeys-steps-actions/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://www.blakfy.com/en/post/mailchimp-complete-guide", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://chimpessentials.com/mailchimp-automation-setup", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "Mailchimp 培训站，可能为伙伴" }, { "url": "https://max-productive.ai/ai-tools/mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20230615596585/en", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "新闻稿，可能为自述" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "mailerlite", "mailchimp" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "segmentation" ], "purpose": "capability", "outcome": "no_result", "discovered_urls": [] }, { "id": "q09", "query": "omnisend blog MailerLite pricing 2026 plans automation conditions", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://www.sender.net/blog/mailerlite-alternatives/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/mailerlite-alternatives/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://sendpulse.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-omnisend", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-constant-contact/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/mailerlite-review/", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/cheap-email-marketing/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/omnisend-vs-mailerlite/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://support.omnisend.com/en/articles/3533018-omnisend-pricing-plans-2026", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "Omnisend 自身价格，与候选无关" }, { "url": "https://workflowunity.io/mailerlite-vs-omnisend/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "mailerlite" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "purpose": "cost", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [ "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/mailerlite-review/" ] }, { "id": "q10", "query": "Mailchimp daily sending limit paid plan campaign 5,000 recipients competitor comparison", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://www.emailtooltester.com/en/reviews/mailchimp/pricing/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "独立测评，不准入" }, { "url": "https://mailchimp.com/help/about-mailchimp-pricing-plans/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://massmailer.io/glossary/mailchimp-salesforce-sending-limits/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "Salesforce 场景，超出范围" }, { "url": "https://www.justanswer.com/email/nhjft-free-account-342-recipients-sent-email.html", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "问答社区，且为免费版" }, { "url": "https://www.retainful.com/blog/mailchimp-pricing", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "可能为竞品，读取预算不足" }, { "url": "https://mailchimp.com/help/about-test-email-sending-limits/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://tinycommand.com/blogs/mailchimp-pricing-explained", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://www.misar.blog/@misarmail/articles/mailchimp-free-plan-limits-2026", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "免费版，归属未明" }, { "url": "https://mailchimp.com/help/about-legacy-pricing-plan/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "mailchimp" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency" ], "purpose": "limitation", "outcome": "no_result", "discovered_urls": [] }, { "id": "q11", "query": "\"MailerLite\" automation \"condition\" branch \"clicked\" comparison Kit OR ActiveCampaign OR Sender OR GetResponse blog", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://www.getresponse.com/blog/mailerlite-alternatives", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.sender.net/compare/mailerlite-vs-activecampaign/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.sender.net/blog/mailerlite-alternatives/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.emailtooltester.com/en/blog/convertkit-vs-activecampaign/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "非本期候选" }, { "url": "https://www.getresponse.com/blog/ai-email-marketing-tools", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "不相关" }, { "url": "https://mattgiaro.com/mailerlite-review/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "个人测评" }, { "url": "https://www.smbguide.com/mailerlite-vs-activecampaign/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "独立媒体" }, { "url": "https://www.getresponse.com/blog/getresponse-vs-mailerlite", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/help/how-to-use-automation-steps", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "mailerlite" ], "scenario_ids": [ "segmentation" ], "purpose": "capability", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [ "https://www.getresponse.com/blog/getresponse-vs-mailerlite" ] }, { "id": "q12", "query": "getresponse.com blog GetResponse vs Brevo automation conditions segmentation", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-vs-getresponse/", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://medium.com/@emmawatsonk/a-comprehensive-comparison-of-getresponse-vs-be8592abc760", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "个人文章" }, { "url": "https://www.emailtooltester.com/en/blog/getresponse-alternatives/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "独立测评" }, { "url": "https://www.brevo.com/getresponse/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "Brevo 自述" }, { "url": "https://www.mailmodo.com/comparison/brevo-vs-getresponse-vs-mailmodo/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://moosend.com/blog/getresponse-alternatives/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "非本期候选" }, { "url": "https://competitors.app/competitors/email-automation-software/brevo-vs-get-response-analysis/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "聚合" }, { "url": "https://www.emailschool.online/articles/brevo-vs-getresponse", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://lite16.com/blog/2026/05/12/brevo-vs-getresponse-affordable-email-marketing-platforms-compared-2/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "brevo" ], "scenario_ids": [ "segmentation" ], "purpose": "capability", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [ "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-vs-getresponse/" ] }, { "id": "q13", "query": "getresponse.com blog GetResponse vs Mailchimp automation branching segmentation", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://www.getresponse.com/blog/mailchimp-vs-getresponse", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://sendpulse.com/blog/getresponse-vs-mailchimp", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/getresponse-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "同家族已有多页" }, { "url": "https://www.mailercloud.com/blog/getresponse-vs-mailchimp", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://moosend.com/blog/mailchimp-vs-getresponse/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.emailtooltester.com/en/blog/getresponse-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "独立测评" }, { "url": "https://www.stylefactoryproductions.com/blog/getresponse-vs-mailchimp", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "独立/联盟" }, { "url": "https://www.nvecta.com/blog/getresponse-vs-mailchimp/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://marketingautomationbuyersguide.com/comparison-mailchimp-vs-getresponse.html", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "mailchimp" ], "scenario_ids": [ "segmentation", "newsletter" ], "purpose": "capability", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [ "https://www.getresponse.com/blog/mailchimp-vs-getresponse" ] }, { "id": "q14", "query": "Brevo Starter plan \"no daily sending limit\" pricing review moosend OR sender OR omnisend", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://www.emailvendorselection.com/brevo-pricing/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "联盟测评站" }, { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-review/", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://moosend.com/blog/brevo-pricing/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://help.brevo.com/hc/en-us/articles/208589409-About-Brevo-s-pricing-plans", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-pricing/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "已读取" }, { "url": "https://www.emailsoftwareinsights.com/reviews/brevo/pricing/free-plan/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://www.sequenzy.com/versus/moosend-vs-brevo", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算优先" }, { "url": "https://www.emailsoftwareinsights.com/reviews/brevo/pricing/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://smtpedia.com/platforms/brevo/pricing/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "brevo" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency" ], "purpose": "limitation", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [ "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-review/" ] }, { "id": "q15", "query": "MailerLite paid plan daily sending limit new account review competitor", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://emailoctopus.com/blog/mailerlite-pricing-update", "rank": null, "opened": true, "skip_reason": null }, { "url": "https://blog.groupmail.io/mailerlite-free-plan-limits/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "预算不足；免费版" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/help/free-plan-update-faq", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/pricing", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商价格页，不能作为证据" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/help/paid-plans-update-faq", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/help/plan-and-billing", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/pricing-mailersend", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述；交易邮件" }, { "url": "https://checkthat.ai/brands/mailerlite/pricing", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://emailforbeginners.com/mailerlite-pricing/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "联盟站" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "mailerlite" ], "scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency" ], "purpose": "limitation", "outcome": "useful", "discovered_urls": [ "https://emailoctopus.com/blog/mailerlite-pricing-update" ] }, { "id": "q16", "query": "MailerLite \"conditional split\" OR \"if/else\" automation review sender.net OR kit.com OR activecampaign.com OR moosend.com", "searched_at": null, "tool": "WebSearch", "locale": null, "results": [ { "url": "https://fayedtion.com/email-workflow-conditional-logic/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://mattgiaro.com/mailerlite-review/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "个人测评" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/features/automation", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/help/split-testing-for-automations", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://www.productowl.io/marketing-automation/mailerlite", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://digi-tools.info/articles/mailerlite-review", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "归属未明" }, { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/help/how-to-use-automation-steps", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "目标厂商自述" }, { "url": "https://bestaiemailtools.com/blog/mailerlite-review-review-2026", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "联盟站" }, { "url": "https://thebestmarketingtool.com/mailerlite-review-tested-every-feature-for-6-months/", "rank": null, "opened": false, "skip_reason": "联盟站" } ], "candidate_ids": [ "mailerlite" ], "scenario_ids": [ "segmentation" ], "purpose": "counterevidence", "outcome": "no_result", "discovered_urls": [] } ], "sources": [ { "id": "s01", "url": "https://mailchimp.com/resources/mailchimp-vs-mailerlite/", "title": "Comparing Mailchimp vs Mailerlite | Mailchimp", "publisher": "Mailchimp", "publisher_product": "Mailchimp", "owner": "Intuit（页面提取显示发布者为 Mailchimp (Intuit)；未另行核实公司页）", "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://mailchimp.com/resources/mailchimp-vs-mailerlite/", "observation": "页面位于 mailchimp.com，以 Mailchimp 身份与 MailerLite 比较" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "两者均出售面向小企业的邮件营销 SaaS，可在三个场景互相替代", "incentive": "贬低 MailerLite 能力以推广自身" }, { "target_candidate_id": "mailchimp", "relationship": "self", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "自家页面", "incentive": "自荐" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-mailchimp", "family_reason": "Mailchimp 自有页面", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": null, "updated_at": null, "effective_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取读取；页面无可见日期；提取非逐字", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s02", "url": "https://mailchimp.com/resources/mailchimp-vs-brevo/", "title": "Comparing Brevo vs Mailchimp | Mailchimp", "publisher": "Mailchimp", "publisher_product": "Mailchimp", "owner": "Intuit（页面提取显示；未另行核实）", "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://mailchimp.com/resources/mailchimp-vs-brevo/", "observation": "页面位于 mailchimp.com，以 Mailchimp 身份与 Brevo 比较" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "brevo", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "均出售邮件营销 SaaS", "incentive": "贬低 Brevo 以推广自身" }, { "target_candidate_id": "mailchimp", "relationship": "self", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "自家页面", "incentive": "自荐" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-mailchimp", "family_reason": "Mailchimp 自有页面", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": null, "updated_at": null, "effective_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取；页面内 Brevo Professional 价格出现 $440 与 $449 两个数，页面自身不一致", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s03", "url": "https://www.brevo.com/blog/mailchimp-alternatives/", "title": "11 Best Free & Paid Mailchimp Alternatives Compared (2026)", "publisher": "Brevo", "publisher_product": "Brevo", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.brevo.com/blog/mailchimp-alternatives/", "observation": "页面位于 brevo.com 博客" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "mailchimp", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "均出售邮件营销 SaaS", "incentive": "推广 Brevo" }, { "target_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "均出售邮件营销 SaaS", "incentive": "推广 Brevo" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-brevo", "family_reason": "Brevo 自有页面", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": null, "updated_at": null, "effective_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "inaccessible", "access_note": "WebFetch 返回的内容被截断，提取模型拒绝给出内容；未读到任何正文段落", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s04", "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/mailchimp-alternative", "title": "MailerLite vs. Mailchimp: Free Mailchimp Alternative - MailerLite", "publisher": "MailerLite", "publisher_product": "MailerLite", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/mailchimp-alternative", "observation": "页面位于 mailerlite.com，以 MailerLite 身份与 Mailchimp 比较" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "mailchimp", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "均出售邮件营销 SaaS", "incentive": "强调 Mailchimp 计费劣势以争取迁移" }, { "target_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "relationship": "self", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "自家页面", "incentive": "自荐" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-mailerlite", "family_reason": "MailerLite 自有页面", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": null, "updated_at": null, "effective_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取；无可见日期；对比表 ✓/— 无明确图例", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s05", "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/brevo-alternative", "title": "Free Brevo (Formerly Sendinblue) Alternative - MailerLite", "publisher": "MailerLite", "publisher_product": "MailerLite", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/brevo-alternative", "observation": "页面位于 mailerlite.com，以 MailerLite 身份与 Brevo 比较" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "brevo", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "均出售邮件营销 SaaS", "incentive": "强调 Brevo 价格与限制以推广自身" }, { "target_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "relationship": "self", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "自家页面", "incentive": "自荐" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-mailerlite", "family_reason": "MailerLite 自有页面", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": null, "updated_at": null, "effective_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取；无可见日期；页面称 Brevo 于 2025 年末重构定价", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s06", "url": "https://www.brevo.com/blog/mailchimp-prices/", "title": "Mailchimp Prices by Plan, Plus Add-ons & Extra Costs", "publisher": "Brevo", "publisher_product": "Brevo", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.brevo.com/blog/mailchimp-prices/", "observation": "页面位于 brevo.com 博客" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "mailchimp", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "均出售邮件营销 SaaS", "incentive": "推广 Brevo" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-brevo", "family_reason": "Brevo 自有页面", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": null, "updated_at": null, "effective_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "inaccessible", "access_note": "WebFetch 仅取回标题，无正文", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s07", "url": "https://www.brevo.com/mailchimp/", "title": "Mailchimp vs. Brevo: 9,000 emails free/month", "publisher": "Brevo", "publisher_product": "Brevo", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.brevo.com/mailchimp/", "observation": "页面位于 brevo.com" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "mailchimp", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "均出售邮件营销 SaaS", "incentive": "推广 Brevo" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-brevo", "family_reason": "Brevo 自有页面", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": null, "updated_at": null, "effective_at": null, "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "inaccessible", "access_note": "WebFetch 仅取回标题，无正文", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s08", "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailerlite/", "title": "Brevo vs. MailerLite (2026): Which Is Best for You?", "publisher": "Omnisend", "publisher_product": "Omnisend", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailerlite/", "observation": "页面位于 omnisend.com 博客；Omnisend 出售邮件/SMS 营销平台" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "brevo", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "Omnisend 出售可替代的邮件营销平台（偏电商）", "incentive": "引导读者考虑 Omnisend" }, { "target_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "同上", "incentive": "同上" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-omnisend", "family_reason": "Omnisend 博客，作者 Karolina Petraškienė", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": "2026-09-16", "updated_at": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-16", "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取；所有权未另行核实", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s09", "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp/", "title": "Brevo vs. Mailchimp (2026): Which Is Better for You?", "publisher": "Omnisend", "publisher_product": "Omnisend", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp/", "observation": "omnisend.com 博客" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "brevo", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "出售可替代邮件营销平台", "incentive": "引导考虑 Omnisend" }, { "target_candidate_id": "mailchimp", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "同上", "incentive": "同上" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-omnisend", "family_reason": "Omnisend 博客", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": "2026-09-08", "updated_at": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-08", "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s10", "url": "https://moosend.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp/", "title": "MailerLite vs Mailchimp: The Ultimate Comparison", "publisher": "Moosend", "publisher_product": "Moosend", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://moosend.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp/", "observation": "moosend.com 博客；Moosend 出售邮件营销 SaaS" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "出售可替代邮件营销 SaaS", "incentive": "引导考虑 Moosend" }, { "target_candidate_id": "mailchimp", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "同上", "incentive": "同上" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-moosend", "family_reason": "Moosend 博客（所有者未在本次核实）", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": "2023-12-12", "updated_at": null, "effective_at": "2023-12-12", "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取；内容为 2023 年，早于 MailerLite 2026 年套餐改名及免费版调整，时效差", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s11", "url": "https://moosend.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp/", "title": "Brevo vs Mailchimp: The Ultimate Comparison", "publisher": "Moosend", "publisher_product": "Moosend", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://moosend.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp/", "observation": "moosend.com 博客" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "brevo", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "出售可替代邮件营销 SaaS", "incentive": "引导考虑 Moosend" }, { "target_candidate_id": "mailchimp", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "同上", "incentive": "同上" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-moosend", "family_reason": "Moosend 博客", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": "2024-01-19", "updated_at": null, "effective_at": "2024-01-19", "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取；2024 年内容，早于 Brevo 2025 年末定价重构", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s12", "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-pricing/", "title": "Brevo Pricing 2026: Plans, Add-On Costs & Who It Fits", "publisher": "Omnisend", "publisher_product": "Omnisend", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-pricing/", "observation": "omnisend.com 博客" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "brevo", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "出售可替代邮件营销平台", "incentive": "强调 Brevo 附加成本" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-omnisend", "family_reason": "Omnisend 博客", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": "2026-09-04", "updated_at": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-04", "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取；联系人上限与发送档的逐档对应未完整呈现", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s13", "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/mailerlite-review/", "title": "Honest MailerLite Review: Pros, Cons, Features & Pricing", "publisher": "Omnisend", "publisher_product": "Omnisend", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/mailerlite-review/", "observation": "omnisend.com 博客" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "出售可替代邮件营销平台", "incentive": "引导考虑 Omnisend" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-omnisend", "family_reason": "Omnisend 博客", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": "2025-09-15", "updated_at": null, "effective_at": "2025-09-15", "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取；使用旧套餐名 Growing Business/Advanced，早于 2026 年改名", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s14", "url": "https://www.getresponse.com/blog/getresponse-vs-mailerlite", "title": "GetResponse vs. MailerLite: 11 Critical Factors to Consider", "publisher": "GetResponse", "publisher_product": "GetResponse", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.getresponse.com/blog/getresponse-vs-mailerlite", "observation": "getresponse.com 博客；GetResponse 出售邮件营销 SaaS" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "出售可替代邮件营销 SaaS", "incentive": "推广 GetResponse" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-getresponse", "family_reason": "GetResponse 博客", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": "2022-01-03", "updated_at": "2025-12-03", "effective_at": "2025-12-03", "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取；更新日早于 MailerLite 2026 年改名/调价", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s15", "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-vs-getresponse/", "title": "Brevo vs. GetResponse: 2026 Comparison", "publisher": "Omnisend", "publisher_product": "Omnisend", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-vs-getresponse/", "observation": "omnisend.com 博客" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "brevo", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "出售可替代邮件营销平台", "incentive": "引导考虑 Omnisend" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-omnisend", "family_reason": "Omnisend 博客", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": "2026-09-14", "updated_at": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-14", "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s16", "url": "https://www.getresponse.com/blog/mailchimp-vs-getresponse", "title": "Mailchimp vs. GetResponse: Which Email Marketing Tool Is Better?", "publisher": "GetResponse", "publisher_product": "GetResponse", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.getresponse.com/blog/mailchimp-vs-getresponse", "observation": "getresponse.com 博客" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "mailchimp", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "出售可替代邮件营销 SaaS", "incentive": "推广 GetResponse" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-getresponse", "family_reason": "GetResponse 博客", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": null, "updated_at": "2025-11-27", "effective_at": "2025-11-27", "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取；页面所列 Mailchimp 价格（1,000 联系人 $26.50/$45）口径不明", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s17", "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-review/", "title": "Brevo Review: Complete Guide & Real User Feedback", "publisher": "Omnisend", "publisher_product": "Omnisend", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.omnisend.com/blog/brevo-review/", "observation": "omnisend.com 博客" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "brevo", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "出售可替代邮件营销平台", "incentive": "引导考虑 Omnisend" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-omnisend", "family_reason": "Omnisend 博客", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": "2025-10-08", "updated_at": null, "effective_at": "2025-10-08", "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取；提取标题为 2025 指南，可能早于 Brevo 2025 年末重构", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s18", "url": "https://emailoctopus.com/blog/mailerlite-pricing-update", "title": "MailerLite pricing update (free tier limits updated) | EmailOctopus", "publisher": "EmailOctopus", "publisher_product": "EmailOctopus", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://emailoctopus.com/blog/mailerlite-pricing-update", "observation": "emailoctopus.com 博客；EmailOctopus 出售邮件营销 SaaS" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "出售可替代邮件营销 SaaS", "incentive": "强调 MailerLite 涨价/免费版收缩以争取用户" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-emailoctopus", "family_reason": "EmailOctopus 博客", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": "2026-06-18", "updated_at": null, "effective_at": "2026-06-18", "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取；未涉及日上限与自动化", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s19", "url": "https://www.mailercloud.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp", "title": "Brevo vs Mailchimp (2026): Which Is Better?", "publisher": "Mailercloud", "publisher_product": "Mailercloud", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.mailercloud.com/blog/brevo-vs-mailchimp", "observation": "mailercloud.com 博客；提取显示 Mailercloud 出售邮件营销软件" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "brevo", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "出售可替代邮件营销 SaaS", "incentive": "推广 Mailercloud" }, { "target_candidate_id": "mailchimp", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "同上", "incentive": "同上" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-mailercloud", "family_reason": "Mailercloud 博客", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": "2026-06-10", "updated_at": "2026-06-10", "effective_at": "2026-06-10", "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取；Brevo 日上限一句较含糊（'更高层级取消'）", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } }, { "id": "s20", "url": "https://www.mailercloud.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp", "title": "MailerLite vs Mailchimp (2026): 14-Round Comparison", "publisher": "Mailercloud", "publisher_product": "Mailercloud", "owner": null, "identity_basis": [ { "url": "https://www.mailercloud.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp", "observation": "mailercloud.com 博客" } ], "relations": [ { "target_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "出售可替代邮件营销 SaaS", "incentive": "推广 Mailercloud" }, { "target_candidate_id": "mailchimp", "relationship": "direct_competitor", "overlapping_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency", "segmentation" ], "basis": "同上", "incentive": "同上" } ], "evidence_family": "fam-mailercloud", "family_reason": "Mailercloud 博客", "upstream_url": null, "published_at": "2026-05-20", "updated_at": "2026-09-22", "effective_at": "2026-09-22", "accessed_at": "2026-09-28", "access_status": "read", "access_note": "经 WebFetch 模型提取；其 MailerLite 免费版数据（500/12,000）与 2026 年 6 月调整后的说法不一致，部分段落可能未随更新", "snapshot": { "sha256": null, "captured_at": null, "captured_scope": null, "status": "unavailable" } } ], "claims": [ { "id": "c-ml-welcome", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "多步欢迎/顺序自动化", "claim_type": "capability", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Mailercloud 称 MailerLite 各套餐均含自动化，覆盖欢迎序列，最多 100 个自动化步骤；Mailchimp 称其为基础自动化、流程上限 100 步；GetResponse 称其支持欢迎邮件系列和 autoresponder。", "interpretation": "两步顺序欢迎流程在三个对手描述的能力范围内。", "scope": { "product_variant": "MailerLite", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "付费套餐（Mailercloud 称含免费档）", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-22" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s20", "locator": "Automation Features 段，MailerLite 小节", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "各套餐含自动化，含欢迎序列、条件分支，最多 100 步", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品以自身名义陈述 MailerLite 能力" }, { "source_id": "s01", "locator": "Automation Capabilities 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "基础自动化能力，流程上限 100 步", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品对 MailerLite 的描述（批评语气，但承认多步流程）" }, { "source_id": "s14", "locator": "Automation / Sequences 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "支持欢迎邮件系列和 autoresponder 等基础自动化", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "未说明延迟、退出条件的具体设置", "各档自动化数量上限不同（见 c-ml-power-triggers）", "均非实测" ], "evidence_strength": "convergent_claims", "strength_reason": "三个不同对手家族在多步欢迎序列这一范围内一致，未见反证" }, { "id": "c-ml-monthly-send", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "付费套餐月发送额度", "claim_type": "quota", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Omnisend（2025-09）称 Growing Business/Advanced 月发送量为 Unlimited；Moosend（2023）称所有付费套餐月群发不限；Omnisend（2026-09）称 MailerLite 按联系人档计费。", "interpretation": "月 8,200 封大概率不受月额度约束；但没有任何对手说明日上限或单次群发速率。", "scope": { "product_variant": "MailerLite", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "旧名 Growing Business/Advanced；2026 年改名为 Comfort/Power", "region": null, "effective_at": "2025-09-15" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s13", "locator": "Sending Limits 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Growing Business 与 Advanced 月发送 Unlimited", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s10", "locator": "Send Limits 段，MailerLite 小节", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "所有付费套餐月群发不限", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述，但为 2023 年" }, { "source_id": "s08", "locator": "MAILERLITE / Pricing Model 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "按联系人档计费", "relation": "context", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "只说明计费口径，提取中的“不限发送”括注是否为原文不确定" } ], "limitations": [ "2026 年改名后 Comfort 的月额度未由已读对手正文明确（检索摘要称为订阅档的 10 倍，但未读正文，不作证据）", "没有日上限或速率信息" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "证据主要早于 2026 年套餐调整，且不涉及峰值" }, { "id": "c-ml-billing-active", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "计费联系人口径", "claim_type": "pricing_structure", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Mailercloud 称 MailerLite 只对活跃订阅者计费，退订和退信不计；Moosend（2023）称不对退订联系人收费。", "interpretation": "保留退订记录（抑制）可能不增加费用。", "scope": { "product_variant": "MailerLite", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-22" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s20", "locator": "Subscriber Billing 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "只对活跃订阅者计费，退订和退信不计", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品以自身名义陈述" }, { "source_id": "s10", "locator": "Pricing & Contact Counting 段，MailerLite 小节", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "退订联系人不收费", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述（2023）" }, { "source_id": "s04", "locator": "Fair pricing 表，MailerLite 列", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "MailerLite 自称只计活跃的唯一订阅者", "relation": "context", "admissibility": "self_promotion", "reason": "目标厂商自述，不能作为证据" } ], "limitations": [ "上游可能是 MailerLite 自述，强度上限 limited", "跨群组重复与归档联系人的计费未由对手说明" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "两个对手家族一致，但可能转述目标厂商资料" }, { "id": "c-ml-editor", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "编辑器选项", "claim_type": "capability", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Moosend 称 MailerLite 提供拖拽、富文本、自定义 HTML 三种编辑器。", "interpretation": "有具体编辑方式描述，但不代表易用性。", "scope": { "product_variant": "MailerLite", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": "2023-12-12" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s10", "locator": "Editor 段，MailerLite 小节", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "三种编辑器", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "2023 年内容，已过时" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一家族且过时" }, { "id": "c-ml-seats", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "用户席位", "claim_type": "limitation", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "criticism", "reported_observation": "Mailchimp 称 MailerLite Growing Business 套餐限 3 个用户席位，无限席位需升级。", "interpretation": "小团队 1–3 人维护够用；更多编辑需更高档。", "scope": { "product_variant": "MailerLite", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Growing Business（旧名）", "region": null, "effective_at": null }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s01", "locator": "Team Collaboration 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Growing Business 限 3 席位", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "使用旧套餐名，改名后是否不变未知" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一对手，日期未知" }, { "id": "c-ml-list-5000", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "5,000 订阅者档价格", "claim_type": "price_point", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "other", "reported_observation": "EmailOctopus（2026-06-18）表格：5,000 订阅者档 Comfort $49/月、Power $69/月；1,000 档 Comfort $19/月。GetResponse（2025-12）称 5,000 订阅者 $50/月（旧套餐）。", "interpretation": "存在可容纳 5,000 联系人的付费档。", "scope": { "product_variant": "MailerLite", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Comfort / Power", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-06-18" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s18", "locator": "Current Plan Names & Pricing 表", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "5,000 订阅者：Comfort $49，Power $69", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s14", "locator": "Pricing 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "5,000 订阅者 $50/月", "relation": "context", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "旧套餐口径，只作背景" } ], "limitations": [ "税费未知", "是否为月付价格按表题推断", "订阅者是否只计活跃联系人见 c-ml-billing-active" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "改名后的价格只有一个对手家族" }, { "id": "c-ml-price-2500-17", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "2,500 订阅者档价格", "claim_type": "price_point", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Mailercloud 表格称 MailerLite 2,500 订阅者 $17/月。", "interpretation": "可能适用于 2,000 名单，但套餐名未注明。", "scope": { "product_variant": "MailerLite", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-22" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s20", "locator": "Pricing at Key Subscriber Levels 表，2,500 行", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "2,500 订阅者 $17/月", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "套餐未注明", "可能未随 2026 年调价更新" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一来源，与其他价格说法冲突" }, { "id": "c-ml-price-2500-20", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "2,500 订阅者档价格", "claim_type": "price_point", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "GetResponse 称 MailerLite 2,500 订阅者 $20/月。", "interpretation": "与 Mailercloud 的 $17 不一致。", "scope": { "product_variant": "MailerLite", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": "2025-12-03" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s14", "locator": "Pricing 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "2,500 订阅者 $20/月", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "早于 2026 年改名/调价", "套餐未注明" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一来源且可能过时" }, { "id": "c-ml-segment-fields", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "按属性分群", "claim_type": "capability", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Mailercloud 称 MailerLite 支持自定义字段筛选、基于互动的分群、标签群组；Moosend 称可按地点、注册来源、时区分群；GetResponse 称可按活动、打开/点击数、购买、地点等分群。", "interpretation": "按联系人属性分群有多个对手描述。", "scope": { "product_variant": "MailerLite", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-22" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s20", "locator": "Segmentation 段，MailerLite", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "自定义字段筛选等", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s10", "locator": "Segmentation 段，MailerLite", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "按地点、来源、时区分群", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述（2023）" }, { "source_id": "s14", "locator": "Segmentation / Capabilities 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "按活动、打开/点击、购买、地点分群", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "各档是否都有该能力未明确" ], "evidence_strength": "convergent_claims", "strength_reason": "三个家族在属性分群范围内一致" }, { "id": "c-ml-branch", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "条件分支自动化", "claim_type": "capability", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Mailercloud 称 MailerLite 自动化支持带条件拆分的分支逻辑。", "interpretation": "可构建基于条件的分支流程；点击条件是否可用未明确。", "scope": { "product_variant": "MailerLite", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-22" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s20", "locator": "Automation Features 段，MailerLite", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "条件拆分的分支逻辑", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "所需套餐档位未说明", "未说明是否可按点击事件分支" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一家族" }, { "id": "c-ml-click-trigger", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "行为触发器", "claim_type": "capability", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "GetResponse 称 MailerLite 自动化可在订阅者加入群组、点击链接、字段更新、纪念日或提交表单时启动。", "interpretation": "存在点击行为触发。", "scope": { "product_variant": "MailerLite", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": "2025-12-03" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s14", "locator": "Automation / Triggers & Conditions 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "触发器包括点击链接", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "触发器不等于分支条件", "早于 2026 年改名" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一家族" }, { "id": "c-ml-power-triggers", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "自动化档位门槛", "claim_type": "limitation", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Omnisend（2026-09-16）称 MailerLite 免费版最多 3 个自动化，Comfort 最多 50 个，无限自动化与多触发器仅限 Power。", "interpretation": "复杂分支流程可能需要 Power 档；本期场景的自动化数量远低于 50。", "scope": { "product_variant": "MailerLite", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Free / Comfort / Power", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-16" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s08", "locator": "MAILERLITE / Automations 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Comfort 50 个自动化；多触发器仅 Power", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "条件分支本身的档位未说明" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一家族" }, { "id": "c-ml-free-250", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "免费版额度", "claim_type": "quota", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "criticism", "reported_observation": "EmailOctopus 与 Omnisend（2026）称 MailerLite 免费版为 250 名活跃订阅者、每月 2,500 封。", "interpretation": "免费版不能承载 2,000 或 5,000 名单，本期场景必须使用付费档。", "scope": { "product_variant": "MailerLite", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Free", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-06-18" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s18", "locator": "Free Plan Changes 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "免费版 250 活跃订阅者、2,500 封/月", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s08", "locator": "MAILERLITE / Free Plan 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "250 联系人、2,500 封/月", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "只作背景，不影响付费档判断" ], "evidence_strength": "convergent_claims", "strength_reason": "两个家族在 2026 年范围内一致" }, { "id": "c-ml-free-500", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "免费版额度（旧口径）", "claim_type": "quota", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Mailchimp 称 MailerLite 免费版覆盖 500 订阅者、付费从 $9/月起；Mailercloud 称免费版为 500 订阅者、12,000 封/月。", "interpretation": "与 2026 年调整后的说法不一致，可能是旧口径。", "scope": { "product_variant": "MailerLite", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Free", "region": null, "effective_at": null }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s01", "locator": "Pricing 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "免费版 500 订阅者，付费 $9 起", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s20", "locator": "Sending Limits 段，MailerLite Free Plan", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "500 订阅者、12,000 封/月", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "可能未随调整更新" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "与更具体的调整说明冲突" }, { "id": "c-br-send-pricing", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "计费口径", "claim_type": "pricing_structure", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Mailchimp、MailerLite、Omnisend、Mailercloud 均称 Brevo 按月发送量计费，而不是按联系人数。", "interpretation": "费用主要随发送量变化；联系人存储另有上限（见 c-br-contact-caps）。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "付费套餐", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-08" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s02", "locator": "Pricing Model 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Brevo 按发送量计费", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s05", "locator": "Pricing & Email Volume 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "按邮件量计费", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s09", "locator": "BREVO / Pricing Model 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "按月发送量而非联系人数计费", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s19", "locator": "BREVO / Contact Billing & Storage 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "按发送计费而非存储联系人", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "退订联系人是否计入存储上限未说明" ], "evidence_strength": "convergent_claims", "strength_reason": "四个家族一致；在计费单位这一范围内未见反证（存储上限为另一维度）" }, { "id": "c-br-contact-caps", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "联系人存储上限", "claim_type": "limitation", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "criticism", "reported_observation": "Omnisend 称 Starter 在较低发送档有 500、1,500、2,500 个联系人上限，选择 20,000 封/月档后可存 500,000；另一篇 Omnisend 称 $32/月（20,000 封档）可存 500,000。MailerLite 称 Brevo 于 2025 年末重构定价并加入联系人上限，$9 起步档为 500 联系人。", "interpretation": "按发送量计费的低价档不一定能存下 2,000 或 5,000 联系人；5,000 联系人在 Starter 可能需要 20,000 封档。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Starter", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-04" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s12", "locator": "Contact Storage Caps by Plan and Tier 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "较低档 500/1,500/2,500，20,000 封档 500,000", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s15", "locator": "Contact & Sending Limits 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "$32/月 20,000 封档可存 500,000", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s05", "locator": "Contact Limits 与 Historical Context 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "2025 年末加入联系人上限；$9 档 500 联系人", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "每个发送档对应哪个联系人上限没有完整读到（如 10,000 封档是否为 1,500）", "退订/抑制联系人是否计入上限未知" ], "evidence_strength": "convergent_claims", "strength_reason": "Omnisend 与 MailerLite 两个家族都说存在上限；逐档对应仍不完整" }, { "id": "c-br-standard-storage", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "Standard 存储上限", "claim_type": "quota", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "other", "reported_observation": "Omnisend 称 Brevo Standard 套餐可存最多 500,000 联系人。", "interpretation": "Standard 档可能不受低档联系人上限约束。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Standard", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-04" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s12", "locator": "Contact Storage Caps 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Standard 可存最多 500,000", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "是否适用于 Standard 所有发送档未明确" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一家族" }, { "id": "c-br-unlimited-2024", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "联系人存储（旧口径）", "claim_type": "quota", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Moosend（2024-01）称 Brevo 所有套餐联系人不限。", "interpretation": "与 2025 年末后的上限说法冲突，属于旧版套餐。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "所有套餐（2024）", "region": null, "effective_at": "2024-01-19" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s11", "locator": "BREVO / Pricing & Contact Counting 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "所有套餐不限联系人", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述，但时效旧" } ], "limitations": [ "早于 2025 年末重构" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "过时" }, { "id": "c-br-no-daily-paid", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "付费档每日上限", "claim_type": "quota", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Omnisend（2025-10）称 Starter 取消了免费版的每日发送上限；Mailercloud（2026-06）称付费的较高层级取消每日上限。", "interpretation": "付费档单日向 2,000 或 5,000 人群发，按对手说法不受 300/日限制。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Starter 及以上", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-06-10" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s17", "locator": "Daily Sending Limits 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Starter 取消免费版每日上限", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s19", "locator": "BREVO / Sending Limits 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "较高层级取消每日上限", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述，但措辞含糊" } ], "limitations": [ "Omnisend 该文可能早于 2025 年末重构", "Standard 是否无日上限需由 'Starter 及以上' 推断", "未提速率限制或新账户审核" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "两个家族，但一条时效存疑、一条措辞含糊" }, { "id": "c-br-free-daily", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "免费版日上限", "claim_type": "quota", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "criticism", "reported_observation": "MailerLite、Omnisend、Mailercloud 均称 Brevo 免费版每天 300 封。", "interpretation": "免费版无法单日完成 2,000 人群发。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Free", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-16" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s05", "locator": "Pricing & Email Volume 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "免费版每天 300 封", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s08", "locator": "BREVO / Free Plan 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "300 封/天", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s19", "locator": "BREVO / Sending Limits 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "免费版 300 封/天", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "只说明免费版" ], "evidence_strength": "convergent_claims", "strength_reason": "三个家族一致" }, { "id": "c-br-welcome", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "多步欢迎自动化", "claim_type": "capability", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Moosend（2024）称 Brevo 所有套餐都可做多步自动化；Mailercloud 称 Brevo 的可视化自动化构建器覆盖欢迎序列等。", "interpretation": "两步欢迎流程在对手描述的能力范围内。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "所有套餐（Moosend 2024 口径）", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-06-10" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s11", "locator": "BREVO / Automation Requirements 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "所有套餐可做多步自动化", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述（2024）" }, { "source_id": "s19", "locator": "BREVO / Automation 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "可视化构建器覆盖欢迎序列", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "Moosend 为 2024 年口径", "Starter 有自动化联系人上限（见 c-br-auto-cap）" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "两个家族，其中一个过时" }, { "id": "c-br-auto-cap", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "自动化联系人上限", "claim_type": "limitation", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "criticism", "reported_observation": "Omnisend 称 Brevo 免费版和 Starter 的自动化只能发给 2,000 个联系人，Starter 以上档不限；另一篇称自动化包含在免费版，上限为每月 2,000 联系人，Standard 取消。", "interpretation": "每月 100 名新订阅者的欢迎流程在 2,000 之内；分支场景若对 2,000 全体做自动化，可能触及上限，需 Standard。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Free / Starter", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-04" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s12", "locator": "Automation Limits 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Free 和 Starter 自动化限 2,000 联系人", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s09", "locator": "BREVO / Automation 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "每月 2,000 联系人上限，Standard 取消", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "'2,000 联系人' 是按月计还是按累计计，口径不明" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一家族" }, { "id": "c-br-ifelse", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "行为触发与 if/else 分支", "claim_type": "capability", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Omnisend（2025-10）称 Brevo 可视化工作流支持复杂的 if/else 逻辑；Omnisend（2026-09）称支持实时事件触发和电商事件。", "interpretation": "行为触发的分支自动化在对手描述范围内。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-08" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s17", "locator": "Automation Features 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "复杂 if/else 逻辑", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s09", "locator": "BREVO / Automation 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "实时事件触发与电商事件", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "所需档位未说明", "未明确可按邮件点击分支" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "只有 Omnisend 一个家族" }, { "id": "c-br-segment", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "分群", "claim_type": "capability", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Moosend 称可通过筛选联系人数据分群；Omnisend 称可按邮件行为、购买历史、网站活动分群并自动更新，另一篇称各套餐都有分群。", "interpretation": "按联系人属性分群在对手描述范围内。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "各套餐（Omnisend 2026-09-16 口径）", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-16" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s11", "locator": "BREVO / Segmentation 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "筛选联系人数据分群", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述（2024）" }, { "source_id": "s17", "locator": "Segmentation 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "按邮件行为、购买、网站活动分群", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s08", "locator": "BREVO / Segmentation 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "各套餐可用", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "与 'advanced segmentation 从 Professional 起' 的说法有档位冲突" ], "evidence_strength": "convergent_claims", "strength_reason": "Moosend 与 Omnisend 两家族一致认为有基础分群；高级分群的档位另有冲突" }, { "id": "c-br-adv-segment-pro", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "高级分群档位", "claim_type": "limitation", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Omnisend（2026-09-14）称 Brevo 的 'advanced segmentation' 从 Professional（$499/月）起。", "interpretation": "部分分群条件可能要高价档，具体哪些条件属于 advanced 不明。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Professional", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-14" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s15", "locator": "Segmentation 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "高级分群从 Professional 起", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "'advanced' 的范围未定义" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一来源，范围含糊" }, { "id": "c-br-seats", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "用户席位", "claim_type": "limitation", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "criticism", "reported_observation": "Mailchimp 称 Brevo Standard 默认只有 1 个用户席位，多用户（10 席）需升级到 Professional（页面内价格 $440 与 $449 并存）。", "interpretation": "多人维护时成本可能大幅上升。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Standard / Professional", "region": null, "effective_at": null }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s02", "locator": "Plan Structure & User Seats 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Standard 1 席位；Professional 多用户", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "页面自身价格不一致；日期未知" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一对手" }, { "id": "c-br-branding", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "去品牌附加费", "claim_type": "pricing_structure", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "criticism", "reported_observation": "MailerLite 与 Omnisend 称 Brevo Starter 去除品牌标识需每月 $12 附加费；Omnisend 称 Standard 及以上默认去除。", "interpretation": "若要求无品牌标识，Starter 实际费用需加 $12。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Starter", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-04" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s05", "locator": "Feature Restrictions 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "去品牌 $12/月附加", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s12", "locator": "Branding Removal 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Starter $12/月；Standard 及以上默认去除", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "年付价格可能不同" ], "evidence_strength": "convergent_claims", "strength_reason": "两个家族一致" }, { "id": "c-br-price-10k-standard", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "Standard 10,000 封档价格", "claim_type": "price_point", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Omnisend 与 MailerLite 均称 Brevo Standard 10,000 封/月为 $35/月；Omnisend 另称 Starter 10,000 封 $17/月，Standard 5,000 封 $18/月。", "interpretation": "newsletter 场景（8,200 封）若用 Standard，参考价约 $35/月。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Standard", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-04" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s12", "locator": "Pricing at Specific Email Volumes 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Standard 10,000 封 $35；Starter 10,000 封 $17", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s05", "locator": "Pricing table，10,000 emails/month 行", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Brevo（Standard）10,000 封 $35", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "税费未知；月付/年付未完全说明", "与 c-br-standard-10k-18 冲突" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "两个家族一致，但存在未解决的冲突说法" }, { "id": "c-br-standard-10k-18", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "Standard 起价", "claim_type": "price_point", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Omnisend（Brevo vs Mailchimp）称 Standard 起价 $18/月、对应 10,000 次发送；Mailchimp 称 Standard $16/月起。", "interpretation": "与 $35/10,000 的说法冲突，可能是发送档对应写错或口径不同。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Standard", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-08" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s09", "locator": "BREVO / Plan Prices 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Standard $18 起，10,000 次发送", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s02", "locator": "Plan Structure & User Seats 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Standard $16/月起", "relation": "context", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "未说明发送档，只作背景" } ], "limitations": [ "发送档对应不清" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "与同家族另一篇冲突" }, { "id": "c-br-price-20k-starter", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "Starter 20,000 封档价格", "claim_type": "price_point", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "other", "reported_observation": "Omnisend 三篇文章称 Brevo Starter 20,000 封/月为 $32/月，并可存 500,000 联系人；年付可省 10%。", "interpretation": "low-frequency 场景存 5,000 联系人的 Starter 参考价约 $32/月（不含税、不含去品牌费）。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Starter 20,000 封/月", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-04" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s12", "locator": "Pricing at Specific Email Volumes / Contact Storage 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Starter 20,000 封 $32，可存 500,000", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s15", "locator": "Contact & Sending Limits 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "$32/月可存 500,000", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s08", "locator": "BREVO / Plan Prices 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "20,000 封 $32（500,000 联系人上限）", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "三篇同属 Omnisend 家族，不构成独立确认", "税费未知" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一家族" }, { "id": "c-br-editor", "candidate_id": "brevo", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "编辑器", "claim_type": "capability", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "concession", "reported_observation": "Moosend（2024）称 Brevo 有拖拽编辑器且运作良好，并提供 A/B 测试。", "interpretation": "有拖拽编辑器；'运作良好' 为主观评价。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Brevo", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": "2024-01-19" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s11", "locator": "BREVO / Editor 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "拖拽编辑器；A/B 测试", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "2024 年；主观评价只能归因呈现" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一家族且过时" }, { "id": "c-mc-contact-billing", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "计费联系人口径", "claim_type": "pricing_structure", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "criticism", "reported_observation": "MailerLite、Moosend、GetResponse、Mailercloud 均称 Mailchimp 按联系人计费，且留在受众中的退订和未确认/非订阅联系人也计入。", "interpretation": "保留退订记录可能推高可计费联系人数，按 '2,000 contacts' 报价可能低估。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Mailchimp", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "付费套餐（Mailercloud 称“部分套餐”）", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-22" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s04", "locator": "Fair pricing 表，Mailchimp 列", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "已订阅、退订和非订阅联系人都计入", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s10", "locator": "MAILCHIMP / Pricing & Contact Counting 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "为退订和未确认联系人付费", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s16", "locator": "Unsubscribed Contact Billing 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "退订和未选择加入的联系人若留在受众中会计入", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s20", "locator": "Subscriber Billing 段，Mailchimp", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "对包括退订和非订阅在内的所有联系人计费", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "Mailercloud 另一篇称是在“部分套餐”", "归档联系人是否计费未说明" ], "evidence_strength": "convergent_claims", "strength_reason": "四个家族一致，未见反证；“部分套餐”的范围差异需核实" }, { "id": "c-mc-duplicate", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "跨受众重复计费", "claim_type": "pricing_structure", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "criticism", "reported_observation": "Moosend（2023）称 Mailchimp 的受众彼此隔离，同一联系人在两个列表中算两个联系人。", "interpretation": "多受众结构可能重复计费。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Mailchimp", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": "2023-12-12" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s10", "locator": "MAILCHIMP / Segmentation 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "不同列表中的同一联系人算两个", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "2023 年" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一家族且过时" }, { "id": "c-mc-send-multiple", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "月发送上限", "claim_type": "quota", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Omnisend 称 Mailchimp 月发送上限为联系人档的倍数：Essentials 10 倍、Standard 12 倍、Premium 15 倍；MailerLite 称为联系人总数的 12 倍（与 Standard 对比）。Moosend 称有月发送上限和超额费。", "interpretation": "2,000 联系人在 Essentials 为 20,000 封/月，覆盖 8,200；但没有日上限信息。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Mailchimp", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Essentials / Standard / Premium", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-08" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s09", "locator": "MAILCHIMP / Send Limits 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Essentials 10x、Standard 12x、Premium 15x", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s04", "locator": "Fair pricing 表", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "月发送为联系人总数 12 倍", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s10", "locator": "MAILCHIMP / Send Limits 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "月发送上限与超额费", "relation": "context", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述（2023）" } ], "limitations": [ "付费档日上限/速率无对手说明" ], "evidence_strength": "convergent_claims", "strength_reason": "两个家族在 Standard 12 倍上一致" }, { "id": "c-mc-free-daily", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "免费版日上限", "claim_type": "quota", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "criticism", "reported_observation": "MailerLite 称 Mailchimp 免费版每月 250 封、每日上限 250 封，最多 250 订阅者。", "interpretation": "免费版不可行；付费档日上限未知。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Mailchimp", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Free", "region": null, "effective_at": null }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s04", "locator": "Fair pricing 表，Free 行", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "免费版 250 封/月、250 封/日", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "只涉及免费版；Omnisend 称免费版 500 封/月，数字不一" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一来源且与他处数字不一" }, { "id": "c-mc-standard-multistep", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "多步与分支自动化门槛", "claim_type": "capability", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "criticism", "reported_observation": "GetResponse 称真正带分支逻辑的多步旅程至少需要 Standard；Omnisend 称 Standard 支持每个流程最多 200 步、多个分支点；Moosend 称多步自动化需 Standard 或以上。", "interpretation": "Standard 档可做两步欢迎流程和分支流程。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Mailchimp", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Standard", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-08" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s16", "locator": "Plan Restrictions 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "带分支的多步旅程至少需 Standard", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s09", "locator": "MAILCHIMP / Automation 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Standard 最多 200 步、多个分支点", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s10", "locator": "MAILCHIMP / Automation Requirements 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "多步需 Standard 或以上", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述（2023）" } ], "limitations": [ "点击事件分支是否可用未明确" ], "evidence_strength": "convergent_claims", "strength_reason": "三个家族一致认为 Standard 支持多步/分支" }, { "id": "c-mc-essentials-single", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "Essentials 自动化限制", "claim_type": "limitation", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "criticism", "reported_observation": "GetResponse（2025-11）称 Essentials 只有单步自动化（一个触发、一封邮件）；Moosend（2024）称 Free/Essentials 只有单步自动化。", "interpretation": "若属实，两步欢迎流程需 Standard。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Mailchimp", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Essentials", "region": null, "effective_at": "2025-11-27" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s16", "locator": "Plan Restrictions 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Essentials 为单步自动化", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s11", "locator": "MAILCHIMP / Automation Requirements 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Free/Essentials 仅单步", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述（2024）" } ], "limitations": [ "与 Omnisend 2026 的 4 步说法冲突" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "存在未解决冲突" }, { "id": "c-mc-essentials-4step", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "Essentials 流程步数", "claim_type": "quota", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "criticism", "reported_observation": "Omnisend（2026-09）称 Mailchimp 免费版无自动化，升级到 Standard 前流程上限为 4 步。", "interpretation": "若属实，Essentials 可能足以做两步欢迎流程。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Mailchimp", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Essentials（推断）", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-08" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s09", "locator": "MAILCHIMP / Automation 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Standard 前流程上限 4 步", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "未明确点名 Essentials" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一来源，与另两家族冲突" }, { "id": "c-mc-behavior-triggers", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "行为触发分支", "claim_type": "capability", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "concession", "reported_observation": "Mailercloud 称 Mailchimp 付费档的 Customer Journey Builder 支持多步分支路径和与电商活动绑定的行为触发；Omnisend 称 Standard 有 Shopify 触发器。", "interpretation": "行为触发的分支自动化在对手描述范围内（以电商行为为例）。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Mailchimp", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "付费档 / Standard", "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-22" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s20", "locator": "Automation Features 段，Mailchimp", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "多步分支路径、电商行为触发", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s09", "locator": "MAILCHIMP / Automation 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "Standard 有 Shopify 触发器", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "点击事件分支未明确提及" ], "evidence_strength": "convergent_claims", "strength_reason": "两个家族在“分支 + 行为触发”范围内一致；点击条件未覆盖" }, { "id": "c-mc-segment-fields", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "按属性分群", "claim_type": "capability", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Mailercloud 称 Mailchimp 可按邮件互动、购买历史、预测人口属性、网站活动和自定义字段组合分群；GetResponse 称所有套餐都有标签；Moosend 称有受众、群组、分群和标签。", "interpretation": "按联系人属性分群在对手描述范围内。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Mailchimp", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-22" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s20", "locator": "Segmentation 段，Mailchimp", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "自定义字段组合等分群", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s16", "locator": "Tagging & Segmentation 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "所有套餐含标签", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" }, { "source_id": "s10", "locator": "MAILCHIMP / Segmentation 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "受众、群组、分群、标签", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "高级分群的档位未说明" ], "evidence_strength": "convergent_claims", "strength_reason": "三个家族一致" }, { "id": "c-mc-export", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "导出含同意状态", "claim_type": "capability", "sensitive": true, "rhetorical_role": "concession", "reported_observation": "Mailercloud 称 Mailchimp 支持带同意状态的 CSV 导出。", "interpretation": "迁移时可能保留退订/同意状态；不代表合规保证。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Mailchimp", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-06-10" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s19", "locator": "MAILCHIMP / Migration/Export 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "CSV 导出含同意状态", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "提取措辞含括注，原句不确定", "不等于合规" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一来源" }, { "id": "c-mc-price-points", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "联系人档价格", "claim_type": "price_point", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "criticism", "reported_observation": "MailerLite 对比表列出 Mailchimp（与 Standard 对比）：2,500 订阅者 $60，5,000 订阅者 $100，均标“功能受限”。", "interpretation": "存在 5,000 联系人档；参考价需核实。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Mailchimp", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": "Standard（据对比表语境）", "region": null, "effective_at": null }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s04", "locator": "Fair pricing 表，Up to 2,500 / 5,000 行", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "2,500 为 $60，5,000 为 $100", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "日期未知；可计费联系人含退订" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一对手" }, { "id": "c-mc-price-2500-45", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "2,500 联系人档价格", "claim_type": "price_point", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Mailercloud 表格称 Mailchimp 2,500 订阅者 $45/月（未注明套餐）。", "interpretation": "与 MailerLite 的 $60 不一致。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Mailchimp", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": "2026-09-22" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s20", "locator": "Pricing at Key Subscriber Levels 表，2,500 行", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "2,500 订阅者 $45", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "套餐未注明" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一来源且冲突" }, { "id": "c-mc-editor", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "baseline_candidate_id": null, "attribute": "编辑器", "claim_type": "capability", "sensitive": false, "rhetorical_role": "comparison", "reported_observation": "Moosend（2023）称 Mailchimp 提供两种不同的构建器，含产品块与问卷。", "interpretation": "有具体编辑方式描述，但不代表易用性。", "scope": { "product_variant": "Mailchimp", "deployment": "SaaS Web", "plan": null, "region": null, "effective_at": "2023-12-12" }, "evidence_links": [ { "source_id": "s10", "locator": "MAILCHIMP / Editor 段", "short_original_excerpt": null, "paraphrase": "两种构建器", "relation": "supports", "admissibility": "eligible", "reason": "直接竞品描述" } ], "limitations": [ "2023 年" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "单一家族且过时" } ], "constraint_matrix": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-automation", "status": "reported_met", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-welcome" ], "explanation": "三个对手家族称 MailerLite 支持多步欢迎序列。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-send", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-monthly-send" ], "explanation": "对手称付费档月发送不限（多为旧套餐口径），但没有任何准入来源说明日上限或单次 2,000 人群发的速率。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-list", "status": "reported_met", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-list-5000" ], "explanation": "EmailOctopus 列出 5,000 订阅者档的 Comfort/Power 价格。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-send", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-monthly-send" ], "explanation": "月额度有线索，单日 5,000 人群发的上限无准入证据。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-rules", "status": "reported_met", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-segment-fields" ], "explanation": "三个家族称支持字段、地点等属性分群。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-branches", "status": "reported_met", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-branch", "c-ml-click-trigger" ], "explanation": "Mailercloud 称有条件拆分分支，GetResponse 称可由点击链接触发；所需档位与“按点击分支”未明确。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-automation", "status": "reported_met", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-welcome", "c-br-auto-cap" ], "explanation": "对手称可做多步自动化、覆盖欢迎序列；Starter 的 2,000 联系人自动化上限高于每月 100 名新订阅者。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-send", "status": "reported_met", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-no-daily-paid", "c-br-standard-storage", "c-br-price-10k-standard", "c-br-contact-caps" ], "explanation": "对手称付费档取消 300/日上限；Standard 可存最多 500,000 联系人并有 10,000 封/月档。Starter 低档的联系人上限可能放不下 2,000 人，因此可行套餐按 Standard 10,000 档理解；Standard 无日上限依据较弱（limited）。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-list", "status": "reported_met", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-contact-caps", "c-br-price-20k-starter", "c-br-standard-storage" ], "explanation": "对手称 Starter 20,000 封档或 Standard 可存 500,000 联系人；较低的 Starter 档（上限最多 2,500）放不下 5,000。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-send", "status": "reported_met", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-no-daily-paid" ], "explanation": "两个对手家族称付费档无免费版的日上限；时效与措辞存疑，强度为 limited。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-rules", "status": "reported_met", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-segment" ], "explanation": "Moosend 与 Omnisend 称可按联系人数据/行为分群；高级分群档位另有冲突。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-branches", "status": "reported_met", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-ifelse" ], "explanation": "Omnisend 称有 if/else 逻辑与实时事件触发；仅一个家族，档位与点击分支未明确。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-automation", "status": "reported_met", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-standard-multistep", "c-mc-essentials-single", "c-mc-essentials-4step" ], "explanation": "三个家族称 Standard 支持多步流程；Essentials 能否做两步存在冲突，只影响档位与成本。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-send", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-send-multiple", "c-mc-free-daily" ], "explanation": "月发送为联系人档 10–12 倍，足够 8,200；付费档日上限没有准入证据（只有免费版的 250/日说法）。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-list", "status": "reported_met", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-price-points" ], "explanation": "MailerLite 对比表列出 Mailchimp 5,000 订阅者档。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-send", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-send-multiple" ], "explanation": "月额度足够，单日 5,000 人群发无准入证据。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-rules", "status": "reported_met", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-segment-fields" ], "explanation": "三个家族描述自定义字段/标签分群。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-branches", "status": "reported_met", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-standard-multistep", "c-mc-behavior-triggers" ], "explanation": "对手称 Standard 有分支，并有电商行为触发；点击分支未明确。" } ], "preference_assessments": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-billing", "status": "supported", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-billing-active" ], "explanation": "对手称只计活跃订阅者；上游可能来自 MailerLite 自述，重复/归档口径未知。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-billing", "status": "supported", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-send-pricing", "c-br-contact-caps" ], "explanation": "按发送量计费，退订不直接增加费用；但存储上限按档位设置，退订是否计入上限未知。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-billing", "status": "opposed", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-contact-billing", "c-mc-duplicate" ], "explanation": "四个家族称退订/非订阅联系人计费；旧资料称跨受众重复计费。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-editor", "status": "supported", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-editor", "c-ml-seats" ], "explanation": "有三种编辑器的具体描述（2023）；旧 Growing Business 档 3 席位。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-editor", "status": "supported", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-editor", "c-br-seats" ], "explanation": "有拖拽编辑器（2024）；但对手称 Standard 只有 1 个席位，多人维护时不利。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-editor", "status": "supported", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-editor" ], "explanation": "有两种构建器的具体描述（2023）。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-structure", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-billing-active", "c-ml-list-5000" ], "explanation": "按活跃联系人档计费；发送频率低不降低费用，但也没有对手分析其低频适配性。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-structure", "status": "supported", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-send-pricing", "c-br-contact-caps", "c-br-price-20k-starter" ], "explanation": "按发送量计费，但存 5,000 联系人需 Starter 20,000 封档（据 Omnisend），不能按 5,000 封最低档计算。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-structure", "status": "opposed", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-contact-billing" ], "explanation": "按联系人（含退订）计费，低频发送不降低费用。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-exit", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "没有对手材料谈到导出或抑制状态保留。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-exit", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "对手只提到自动退订处理，未谈导出。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-exit", "status": "supported", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-export" ], "explanation": "Mailercloud 称可导出含同意状态的 CSV；单一来源。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-tier", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-power-triggers" ], "explanation": "多触发器仅 Power，分支所需档位未知。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-tier", "status": "conflicting", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-segment", "c-br-adv-segment-pro", "c-br-auto-cap" ], "explanation": "一说各套餐有分群，一说高级分群从 Professional 起；Starter 自动化另有 2,000 联系人上限。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-tier", "status": "supported", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-standard-multistep", "c-mc-segment-fields" ], "explanation": "分支需 Standard，分群/标签在更低档已有，因此 Standard 同时具备两者。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-data", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "无对手说明导出与集成的具体动作。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-data", "status": "unknown", "claim_ids": [], "explanation": "对手只给出集成数量，不按数量排名；导出未谈。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-data", "status": "supported", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-export" ], "explanation": "单一对手称有含同意状态的 CSV 导出。" } ], "cost_comparisons": [ { "scenario_id": "newsletter", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "status": "conflicting", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": "monthly", "commitment": null, "plan": null, "workload": { "billable_contacts": 2000, "sends_per_month": 8200 }, "inputs": [ { "name": "2,500 订阅者档月价（Mailercloud）", "value": 17, "unit": "USD/月", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-price-2500-17" ] }, { "name": "2,500 订阅者档月价（GetResponse，旧套餐）", "value": 20, "unit": "USD/月", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-price-2500-20" ] } ], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "2026 年改名后 Comfort 2,000–2,500 档的确切价格", "税费", "日上限是否需要更高档" ], "excluded_costs": [ "迁移、域名设置、人工维护" ], "caveat": "两个对手给出的价格不一致，且都早于或不确定是否反映 2026 年调价；不算单一数字。" }, { "scenario_id": "newsletter", "candidate_id": "brevo", "status": "conflicting", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": "monthly", "commitment": null, "plan": "Standard 10,000 封/月", "workload": { "stored_contacts": 2000, "sends_per_month": 8200 }, "inputs": [ { "name": "Standard 10,000 封/月", "value": 35, "unit": "USD/月", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-price-10k-standard" ] }, { "name": "Standard 起价（称对应 10,000 次发送）", "value": 18, "unit": "USD/月", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-standard-10k-18" ] }, { "name": "Starter 10,000 封/月（联系人上限未知）", "value": 17, "unit": "USD/月", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-price-10k-standard" ] }, { "name": "Starter 去品牌附加", "value": 12, "unit": "USD/月", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-branding" ] } ], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "Starter 10,000/15,000 档对应的联系人上限", "Standard 10,000 档的确切价格（$35 与 $18 冲突）", "税费" ], "excluded_costs": [ "迁移、域名设置、人工维护", "多席位升级" ], "caveat": "价格说法冲突，且 Starter 能否存下 2,000 联系人未知；按发送计费的单位不能与按联系人计费的产品直接相除比较。" }, { "scenario_id": "newsletter", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "status": "conflicting", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": "monthly", "commitment": null, "plan": "Standard（若 Essentials 不能做两步）", "workload": { "billable_contacts": "≥2000（含退订）", "sends_per_month": 8200 }, "inputs": [ { "name": "2,500 联系人档（MailerLite 表，Standard 语境）", "value": 60, "unit": "USD/月", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-price-points" ] }, { "name": "2,500 联系人档（Mailercloud，套餐未注明）", "value": 45, "unit": "USD/月", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-price-2500-45" ] } ], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "实际可计费联系人数（含退订/非订阅）", "Essentials 是否足够（步数冲突）", "付费档日上限", "税费" ], "excluded_costs": [ "迁移、域名设置、人工维护" ], "caveat": "价格冲突，且计费联系人可能多于 2,000。" }, { "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "status": "incomplete", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": "monthly", "commitment": null, "plan": "Comfort 5,000 订阅者档", "workload": { "billable_contacts": 5000, "sends_per_month": 5000 }, "inputs": [ { "name": "Comfort 5,000 订阅者", "value": 49, "unit": "USD/月", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-list-5000" ] }, { "name": "Power 5,000 订阅者", "value": 69, "unit": "USD/月", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-list-5000" ] } ], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "单日 5,000 封是否受限（决定可行档）", "税费", "年付/月付口径" ], "excluded_costs": [ "迁移、人工维护" ], "caveat": "硬约束 low-send 未知，所以不给可行套餐的估算。" }, { "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "candidate_id": "brevo", "status": "incomplete", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": "monthly", "commitment": "月付（年付约省 10%，据 Omnisend）", "plan": "Starter 20,000 封/月", "workload": { "stored_contacts": 5000, "sends_per_month": 5000 }, "inputs": [ { "name": "Starter 20,000 封/月（可存 500,000 联系人）", "value": 32, "unit": "USD/月", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-price-20k-starter", "c-br-contact-caps" ] }, { "name": "Starter 去品牌附加（可选）", "value": 12, "unit": "USD/月", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-branding" ] } ], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "税费", "退订/抑制联系人是否计入存储上限", "价格仅来自 Omnisend 一个家族" ], "excluded_costs": [ "去品牌附加（非硬约束）", "迁移、人工维护" ], "caveat": "只是单一对手家族给出的软件标价，不是总拥有成本；每月只发 5,000 封，却需要买 20,000 封档来存联系人。" }, { "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "status": "incomplete", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": "monthly", "commitment": null, "plan": "Standard（据 MailerLite 对比表语境）", "workload": { "billable_contacts": "≥5000（含退订）", "sends_per_month": 5000 }, "inputs": [ { "name": "5,000 订阅者档", "value": 100, "unit": "USD/月", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-price-points" ] } ], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "Essentials 5,000 档价格", "含退订的实际计费联系人数", "付费档日上限", "税费" ], "excluded_costs": [ "迁移、人工维护" ], "caveat": "单一对手数据，日期未知，且 low-send 未知。" }, { "scenario_id": "segmentation", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "status": "incomplete", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": null, "commitment": null, "plan": null, "workload": { "billable_contacts": 2000, "sends_per_month": 9000 }, "inputs": [], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "点击分支需要 Comfort 还是 Power", "对应档位 2,000–2,500 联系人价格" ], "excluded_costs": [ "实施与维护" ], "caveat": "档位门槛未知。" }, { "scenario_id": "segmentation", "candidate_id": "brevo", "status": "conflicting", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": "monthly", "commitment": null, "plan": "Standard 10,000 封/月（解除 Starter 自动化上限）", "workload": { "stored_contacts": 2000, "sends_per_month": 9000 }, "inputs": [ { "name": "Standard 10,000 封/月", "value": 35, "unit": "USD/月", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-price-10k-standard" ] }, { "name": "Standard 起价（称对应 10,000 次发送）", "value": 18, "unit": "USD/月", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-standard-10k-18" ] } ], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "所需分群是否属于 Professional 才有的高级分群", "价格冲突", "税费" ], "excluded_costs": [ "实施与维护" ], "caveat": "若需 Professional，对手称价格约 $449–$499/月，成本结构完全不同。" }, { "scenario_id": "segmentation", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "status": "incomplete", "currency": "USD", "billing_period": null, "commitment": null, "plan": "Standard", "workload": { "billable_contacts": "≥2000（含退订）", "sends_per_month": 9000 }, "inputs": [], "formula": null, "estimated_software_cost": null, "missing_inputs": [ "Standard 2,000 联系人档价格", "实际可计费联系人数" ], "excluded_costs": [ "实施与维护" ], "caveat": "无可用单价。" } ], "conflicts": [ { "id": "cf-mc-essentials", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-essentials-single", "c-mc-essentials-4step" ], "affected_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter" ], "description": "GetResponse（2025-11）与 Moosend（2024）称 Essentials 只有单步自动化；Omnisend（2026-09）称升级到 Standard 前流程最多 4 步。", "scope_comparison": "同一产品与套餐，日期不同；Omnisend 未明确点名 Essentials。", "disposition": "unresolved", "rationale": "较新日期本身不能解决冲突。它只影响两步欢迎流程可用的最低档，不影响 Standard 可行的判断。", "required_verification": "用试用账户在 Essentials 档尝试建立两步欢迎流程。" }, { "id": "cf-br-contacts", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-unlimited-2024", "c-br-contact-caps" ], "affected_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency" ], "description": "Moosend（2024）称所有套餐联系人不限；Omnisend（2026）与 MailerLite 称存在按档位的联系人上限。", "scope_comparison": "MailerLite 页面明确称 Brevo 于 2025 年末重构定价、加入联系人上限，两者属于不同套餐版本。", "disposition": "resolved_scope_difference", "rationale": "不是只凭日期较新：另有对手说明了套餐版本变化，Moosend 描述的是重构前的套餐。", "required_verification": "在 Brevo 定价页核对每个发送档对应的联系人上限。" }, { "id": "cf-br-price", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-price-10k-standard", "c-br-standard-10k-18" ], "affected_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "segmentation" ], "description": "Standard 10,000 封/月：$35（Omnisend 定价文、MailerLite）与 $18（Omnisend 对比文）/ $16 起（Mailchimp）不一致。", "scope_comparison": "同一套餐，发送档对应可能写错；Omnisend 定价文称 $18 对应 5,000 封。", "disposition": "unresolved", "rationale": "无法从准入来源确定哪一个数字正确。", "required_verification": "在定价页选择 Standard、10,000 封、月付，记录美元价格。" }, { "id": "cf-ml-free", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-free-250", "c-ml-free-500" ], "affected_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency" ], "description": "MailerLite 免费版：250/2,500（EmailOctopus、Omnisend 2026）与 500 订阅者（Mailchimp、Mailercloud）不一致。", "scope_comparison": "EmailOctopus 明确记录了免费版调整，属于不同版本。", "disposition": "resolved_scope_difference", "rationale": "有对手记录版本变化；免费版本来也不能承载本期场景，不影响决策。", "required_verification": "无需，除非改为评估免费版。" }, { "id": "cf-ml-price", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-price-2500-17", "c-ml-price-2500-20" ], "affected_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter" ], "description": "MailerLite 2,500 订阅者档价格 $17 与 $20 不一致。", "scope_comparison": "套餐未注明，日期不同，均可能早于 2026 年调价。", "disposition": "unresolved", "rationale": "无法判断哪一个适用于当前 Comfort 档。", "required_verification": "在定价页核对 Comfort 2,500 档的月付价格。" }, { "id": "cf-mc-price", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-price-points", "c-mc-price-2500-45" ], "affected_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter" ], "description": "Mailchimp 2,500 联系人档价格 $60（MailerLite）与 $45（Mailercloud）不一致。", "scope_comparison": "套餐可能不同（Standard 与未注明）。", "disposition": "unresolved", "rationale": "套餐口径不明。", "required_verification": "在定价页核对 Essentials/Standard 2,500 档价格。" }, { "id": "cf-br-seg-tier", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-segment", "c-br-adv-segment-pro" ], "affected_scenario_ids": [ "segmentation" ], "description": "一说各套餐都有分群，一说高级分群从 Professional 起。", "scope_comparison": "'advanced' 的范围未定义，可能是基础与高级分群之分。", "disposition": "unresolved", "rationale": "不能确定本场景所需的属性 + 点击条件属于哪一类。", "required_verification": "在 Starter/Standard 试用中创建“属性 + 点击”组合分群。" } ], "scenario_decisions": [ { "scenario_id": "newsletter", "disposition": "investigate_first", "candidate_outcomes": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "disposition": "investigate_first", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-welcome", "c-ml-monthly-send", "c-ml-billing-active" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-ml-daily", "g-billing-detail" ], "reason": "欢迎自动化有多个对手家族的支持；单次 2,000 人群发的日上限没有准入证据。这是缺证据，不是否定说法。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "disposition": "investigate_first", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-welcome", "c-br-auto-cap", "c-br-no-daily-paid", "c-br-standard-storage", "c-br-price-10k-standard" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-br-tier-map" ], "reason": "原始输出同时记录了涉及该选择的未解决冲突，发布前保守降为先核实。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "disposition": "investigate_first", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-standard-multistep", "c-mc-send-multiple", "c-mc-contact-billing" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-mc-daily", "g-mc-essentials" ], "reason": "Standard 可做多步流程，月额度足够；付费档日上限没有准入证据。" } ], "comparative": { "status": "insufficient_basis", "preferred_candidate_id": null, "comparison_claim_ids": [], "reason": "MailerLite 与 Mailchimp 的日上限缺证据不等于不满足；在决定性标准上没有可比证据，Brevo 不能因此默认胜出。" }, "options": [], "abstention_reason": "推荐所涉冲突未解决，先核实。", "verification_plan": [ { "question": "MailerLite 与 Mailchimp 付费档能否在一天内向 2,000 人群发？", "method": "在试用账户中向团队控制的测试名单小批量发送，并查阅各自帮助文档中的发送限制（产品事实核实，不属于本期竞品证据）", "success_criterion": "文档或账户界面明确无日上限，或日上限 ≥2,000", "status": "not_executed" }, { "question": "Brevo 存 2,000 联系人、每月 ≥8,200 封的最低档是哪一档，价格多少？", "method": "在 Brevo 定价页选择对应的联系人数与发送量", "success_criterion": "得到明确档位、美元月价，以及是否有日上限", "status": "not_executed" }, { "question": "Mailchimp Essentials 能否建立两步欢迎流程？", "method": "试用账户建立两步流程", "success_criterion": "可激活包含两封邮件的流程", "status": "not_executed" } ] }, { "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "disposition": "conditional_shortlist", "candidate_outcomes": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "disposition": "investigate_first", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-list-5000", "c-ml-monthly-send" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-ml-daily", "g-ml-export" ], "reason": "有 5,000 档价格；单日 5,000 人群发无准入证据。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "disposition": "shortlisted", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-contact-caps", "c-br-price-20k-starter", "c-br-no-daily-paid" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-br-tier-map", "g-br-export" ], "reason": "对手称 Starter 20,000 档可存 500,000 联系人且无免费版日上限；证据 limited。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "disposition": "investigate_first", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-price-points", "c-mc-send-multiple", "c-mc-contact-billing" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-mc-daily" ], "reason": "有 5,000 档；付费档单日上限无准入证据，计费含退订。" } ], "comparative": { "status": "insufficient_basis", "preferred_candidate_id": null, "comparison_claim_ids": [], "reason": "其他候选的日上限未知；Brevo 的价格只有单一家族；不同计费单位不能直接比较。" }, "options": [ { "candidate_id": "brevo", "best_for": "需要保留约 5,000 名许可联系人、每月只群发一次的组织。", "not_for": "计划很快把名单扩大到远超 Starter 档联系人上限、又不愿按存储需求买更高发送档的团队；或需要多人维护的团队。", "supporting_claim_ids": [ "c-br-contact-caps", "c-br-price-20k-starter", "c-br-no-daily-paid", "c-br-send-pricing" ], "counter_claim_ids": [ "c-br-seats", "c-br-branding", "c-br-unlimited-2024" ], "constraint_refs": [ "brevo/low-frequency/low-list", "brevo/low-frequency/low-send" ], "tradeoff": "“按发送量计费”在这里并不是按 5,000 封计价：据 Omnisend，要存 5,000 联系人，Starter 需选 20,000 封档（约 $32/月）。MailerLite 的 Comfort 5,000 档据 EmailOctopus 为 $49/月，但单位不同，而且其日上限未知，不能直接判胜负。", "alternative_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "reversal_condition": "若定价页显示 5,000 联系人需更高档或更高价，或付费档存在低于 5,000 的日上限，则改为先核实其他候选。", "prerequisites": [ "确认存 5,000 联系人的最低档与价格", "确认退订/抑制联系人是否计入存储上限", "确认导出时能保留退订状态" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "价格与存储上限只来自 Omnisend 一个家族；日上限证据时效存疑。" } ], "abstention_reason": null, "verification_plan": [ { "question": "MailerLite/Mailchimp 付费档单日能否发送 5,000 封？", "method": "查阅帮助文档，或在试用账户中确认发送限制（不向真实名单群发）", "success_criterion": "日上限 ≥5,000 或无日上限", "status": "not_executed" }, { "question": "各候选能否导出联系人及退订/抑制状态？", "method": "试用账户导入含已退订测试联系人的小名单后导出", "success_criterion": "导出文件保留退订状态字段", "status": "not_executed" } ] }, { "scenario_id": "segmentation", "disposition": "conditional_shortlist", "candidate_outcomes": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "disposition": "shortlisted", "claim_ids": [ "c-ml-segment-fields", "c-ml-branch", "c-ml-click-trigger" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-ml-branch-tier", "g-click-branch", "g-ml-export" ], "reason": "两项硬约束都有对手说法支持；分支所需档位（Comfort 或 Power）与点击分支需核实。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "disposition": "investigate_first", "claim_ids": [ "c-br-segment", "c-br-ifelse" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-click-branch", "g-br-export" ], "reason": "原始输出同时记录了涉及该选择的未解决冲突，发布前保守降为先核实。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "disposition": "shortlisted", "claim_ids": [ "c-mc-segment-fields", "c-mc-standard-multistep", "c-mc-behavior-triggers" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-click-branch" ], "reason": "对手称 Standard 有分支与行为触发，分群多家族一致；点击分支未明确。" } ], "comparative": { "status": "insufficient_basis", "preferred_candidate_id": null, "comparison_claim_ids": [], "reason": "三者对“按点击事件分支”和档位门槛的证据都不完整，无法比较优先顺序。" }, "options": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "best_for": "按字段/群组分群，并用简单条件分支做跟进的小名单。", "not_for": "需要多触发器或复杂多路分支，却不打算升级 Power 的团队。", "supporting_claim_ids": [ "c-ml-segment-fields", "c-ml-branch", "c-ml-click-trigger" ], "counter_claim_ids": [ "c-ml-power-triggers" ], "constraint_refs": [ "mailerlite/segmentation/segment-rules", "mailerlite/segmentation/segment-branches" ], "tradeoff": "对手称其按活跃订阅者计费；多触发器只在 Power 档。Mailchimp 的 Standard 档门槛描述更一致，但按含退订的联系人计费。", "alternative_candidate_id": "mailchimp", "reversal_condition": "若 Comfort 不能按点击分支、而 Power 价格超出预算，或条件拆分不支持点击事件，则重新评估。", "prerequisites": [ "确认 Comfort 是否可建立“点击链接”条件分支", "用测试邮箱验证属性分群与点击分支" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "分支能力只有 Mailercloud 一个家族支持。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "best_for": "已准备使用 Standard 档、需要自定义字段分群与多步分支流程的团队。", "not_for": "在意退订联系人计费，或只打算用 Essentials 的团队。", "supporting_claim_ids": [ "c-mc-segment-fields", "c-mc-standard-multistep", "c-mc-behavior-triggers" ], "counter_claim_ids": [ "c-mc-contact-billing", "c-mc-essentials-single" ], "constraint_refs": [ "mailchimp/segmentation/segment-rules", "mailchimp/segmentation/segment-branches" ], "tradeoff": "分群与分支都在 Standard 档；但对手一致称退订/非订阅联系人计费。最强替代是 MailerLite。", "alternative_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "reversal_condition": "若 Standard 不能按邮件点击分支，或含退订后的计费联系人使费用超出预算。", "prerequisites": [ "确认 Standard 可按点击事件分支", "统计现有名单中退订/非订阅联系人数" ], "evidence_strength": "limited", "strength_reason": "点击分支未被任何对手明确提及；按规则，推荐强度不能超过最弱的决定性命题。" } ], "abstention_reason": null, "verification_plan": [ { "question": "三者能否在所需档位按“订阅者属性 + 邮件点击”分支？", "method": "试用账户用团队控制的测试邮箱建立流程：点击与未点击走不同分支", "success_criterion": "两条分支都被正确触发，并在报告中可见", "status": "not_executed" }, { "question": "能否导出联系人与抑制状态？", "method": "试用账户导出", "success_criterion": "导出文件包含退订/抑制字段", "status": "not_executed" } ] } ], "coverage_matrix": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "eligible_family_ids": [ "fam-mailercloud", "fam-mailchimp", "fam-getresponse", "fam-omnisend", "fam-moosend" ], "supported_constraints": [ "newsletter-automation" ], "unknown_constraints": [ "newsletter-send" ], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q15", "q08" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-ml-daily", "g-billing-detail" ] }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "eligible_family_ids": [ "fam-emailoctopus", "fam-getresponse", "fam-omnisend" ], "supported_constraints": [ "low-list" ], "unknown_constraints": [ "low-send" ], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q15" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-ml-daily", "g-ml-export" ] }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "eligible_family_ids": [ "fam-mailercloud", "fam-getresponse", "fam-moosend", "fam-omnisend" ], "supported_constraints": [ "segment-rules", "segment-branches" ], "unknown_constraints": [], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q16" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-ml-branch-tier", "g-click-branch", "g-ml-export" ] }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "eligible_family_ids": [ "fam-omnisend", "fam-moosend", "fam-mailercloud", "fam-mailchimp", "fam-mailerlite" ], "supported_constraints": [ "newsletter-automation", "newsletter-send" ], "unknown_constraints": [], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q07", "q14" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-br-tier-map", "g-brevo-pages" ] }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "eligible_family_ids": [ "fam-omnisend", "fam-mailercloud", "fam-mailerlite", "fam-mailchimp" ], "supported_constraints": [ "low-list", "low-send" ], "unknown_constraints": [], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q07", "q14" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-br-tier-map", "g-br-export" ] }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "eligible_family_ids": [ "fam-omnisend", "fam-moosend" ], "supported_constraints": [ "segment-rules", "segment-branches" ], "unknown_constraints": [], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q12" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-click-branch", "g-br-export" ] }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "eligible_family_ids": [ "fam-omnisend", "fam-getresponse", "fam-moosend", "fam-mailerlite", "fam-mailercloud" ], "supported_constraints": [ "newsletter-automation" ], "unknown_constraints": [ "newsletter-send" ], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q10", "q08" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-mc-daily", "g-mc-essentials", "g-brevo-pages" ] }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "eligible_family_ids": [ "fam-mailerlite", "fam-omnisend", "fam-mailercloud" ], "supported_constraints": [ "low-list" ], "unknown_constraints": [ "low-send" ], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q10" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-mc-daily" ] }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "eligible_family_ids": [ "fam-getresponse", "fam-omnisend", "fam-mailercloud", "fam-moosend" ], "supported_constraints": [ "segment-rules", "segment-branches" ], "unknown_constraints": [], "counterevidence_search_ids": [ "q13" ], "gap_ids": [ "g-click-branch" ] } ], "excluded": [ { "source_id": "s04", "target_candidate_id": "mailerlite", "locator": "Fair pricing 表，MailerLite 列（只计活跃唯一订阅者、Power 不限发送）", "reason": "目标厂商自述（self_promotion）", "effect_on_decision": "不作为 MailerLite 计费口径或发送额度的证据；该偏好只依据 Mailercloud/Moosend 的说法，强度为 limited。" } ], "coverage_gaps": [ { "id": "g-ml-daily", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": null, "question": "MailerLite Comfort/Power 付费档是否有日发送上限、速率限制或新账户审核？", "why_missing": "已读的对手材料都没有提到；检索到的相关页面多为 MailerLite 自述，不准入。", "decision_impact": "导致 newsletter-send 与 low-send 为 unknown，候选只能列为 investigate_first。", "next_action": "查阅 MailerLite 文档或试用账户（在本期政策之外核实）。" }, { "id": "g-mc-daily", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": null, "question": "Mailchimp 付费档是否有日发送上限？", "why_missing": "对手只谈到免费版的日上限；检索到的是 Mailchimp 自述或来源不明的页面。", "decision_impact": "newsletter-send 与 low-send 为 unknown。", "next_action": "查阅 Mailchimp 文档或试用账户。" }, { "id": "g-br-tier-map", "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": null, "question": "Brevo 各发送档对应的联系人上限是多少？Standard 是否确实没有日上限？", "why_missing": "对手只列出 500/1,500/2,500/500,000 这几个上限，没有完整的逐档对应。", "decision_impact": "影响可行档位与价格；是 Brevo 入选的前提条件。", "next_action": "在定价页核对。" }, { "id": "g-ml-branch-tier", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "question": "条件分支（含点击条件）在 Comfort 档是否可用？", "why_missing": "对手只说多触发器仅 Power，没有说明条件分支的档位。", "decision_impact": "影响档位与成本。", "next_action": "试用 Comfort 档。" }, { "id": "g-click-branch", "candidate_id": null, "scenario_id": "segmentation", "question": "三者能否按“邮件点击”事件分支？", "why_missing": "对手描述的是分支或行为触发，没有逐一确认点击分支。", "decision_impact": "是 segmentation 场景的核心工作流，目前只有 limited 支持。", "next_action": "用测试邮箱做分支验证。" }, { "id": "g-ml-export", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "question": "能否导出联系人及退订/抑制状态？", "why_missing": "没有对手材料提到。", "decision_impact": "影响 low-exit/segment-data 偏好。", "next_action": "试用导出。" }, { "id": "g-br-export", "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "question": "能否导出联系人及退订/抑制状态？", "why_missing": "对手只提到自动退订处理。", "decision_impact": "影响 low-exit/segment-data 偏好。", "next_action": "试用导出。" }, { "id": "g-billing-detail", "candidate_id": null, "scenario_id": "newsletter", "question": "归档联系人、跨群组重复联系人在 MailerLite 与 Brevo 存储上限中如何计算？", "why_missing": "对手没有谈到。", "decision_impact": "影响计费口径偏好与成本。", "next_action": "查阅各自计费说明。" }, { "id": "g-brevo-pages", "candidate_id": null, "scenario_id": null, "question": "Brevo 自己发布的对比页如何描述 MailerLite 与 Mailchimp？", "why_missing": "3 个 Brevo 页面的正文都无法读取（被截断或只取回标题）。", "decision_impact": "少了一个评价 MailerLite/Mailchimp 的对手家族。", "next_action": "下一轮用其他抓取方式重试。" }, { "id": "g-mc-essentials", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "question": "Essentials 能否做两步欢迎流程？", "why_missing": "对手说法冲突。", "decision_impact": "影响最低可行档与成本。", "next_action": "试用 Essentials。" }, { "id": "g-costs-tax", "candidate_id": null, "scenario_id": null, "question": "税费、年付折扣、超额规则如何？", "why_missing": "对手材料大多没有说明。", "decision_impact": "所有成本都是 incomplete 或 conflicting。", "next_action": "核对定价页。" }, { "id": "g-deliverability", "candidate_id": null, "scenario_id": null, "question": "进箱率、送达率与合规（同意记录、GDPR）", "why_missing": "按协议不能用竞品营销说法证明，本期未评估。", "decision_impact": "不影响本期的适配判断，但也没有得到任何保证。", "next_action": "用受控小样本测试流程；进箱表现需要独立的方法评估。" }, { "id": "g-fetch-verbatim", "candidate_id": null, "scenario_id": null, "question": "提取内容是否为逐字原文？", "why_missing": "WebFetch 返回的是模型处理后的提取，无法保证逐字准确。", "decision_impact": "所有命题都可能有转述误差；摘录置 null。", "next_action": "发布前由人工逐页核对定位段落。" } ], "future_candidates": [ { "name": "Omnisend", "discovery_source_ids": [ "s08", "s09" ], "why_consider_later": "在多篇对比中作为替代出现，偏电商；需另行修订计划才能纳入。" }, { "name": "GetResponse", "discovery_source_ids": [ "s14", "s16" ], "why_consider_later": "自称自动化能力更强，可作为分支场景的候选。" }, { "name": "EmailOctopus", "discovery_source_ids": [ "s18" ], "why_consider_later": "低价 newsletter 替代。" }, { "name": "Moosend", "discovery_source_ids": [ "s10", "s11" ], "why_consider_later": "对手称其发送不限量，可用于 low-frequency 对照。" } ], "completion": { "queries_used": 16, "url_read_attempts": 20, "stop_reason": "正文读取预算（20 次）已用尽，其中 3 次失败（Brevo 页面）。MailerLite 与 Mailchimp 付费档的日上限仍没有准入证据，因此状态为 partial。", "unfinished_tasks": [ "MailerLite 与 Mailchimp 付费档的日上限", "Brevo 逐档联系人上限", "三者的点击分支与导出/抑制状态", "Brevo 自己的对比页（读取失败）" ], "checks": [ { "check": "每条影响选择的命题有已读的准入段落", "outcome": "pass", "note": "所有 supports 链接都来自已读的对手页面；但读取内容是模型提取，不是逐字原文。" }, { "check": "自荐、间接自述未进入推荐证据", "outcome": "pass", "note": "MailerLite 自述已排除；c-ml-billing-active 因可能转述自述，强度上限为 limited。" }, { "check": "每个候选都出现在覆盖表", "outcome": "pass", "note": "9 个候选 × 场景组合都有记录。" }, { "check": "硬约束没有被推断通过", "outcome": "pass", "note": "Brevo newsletter-send 结合了“Starter 及以上无日上限”与“Standard 存储上限”两条命题，已在 explanation 中披露，强度为 limited。" }, { "check": "成本单位可比", "outcome": "pass", "note": "没有跨单位相除；全部标为 incomplete 或 conflicting。" }, { "check": "JSON 引用完整", "outcome": "pass", "note": "人工自查；仍需宿主用校验器确认。" }, { "check": "摘录逐字可核", "outcome": "not_assessable", "note": "工具不返回原文，short_original_excerpt 全部为 null。" } ] } } } ], "integration": { "category_id": "email-marketing", "constraint_matrix": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-automation", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-send", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-automation", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-send", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-automation", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "constraint_id": "newsletter-send", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-list", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-send", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-list", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-send", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-list", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "constraint_id": "low-send", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-rules", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-branches", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-rules", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-branches", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-rules", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "constraint_id": "segment-branches", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "完整工作负载和当前套餐尚未复核通过；文章仅提供试用方向。", "evidence_refs": [] } ], "preference_assessments": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-billing", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-editor", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-billing", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-editor", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-billing", "status": "supported", "explanation": "有计费或维护线索，仍不支持相对排名。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c3" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-editor", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-structure", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-exit", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-structure", "status": "supported", "explanation": "有计费或维护线索，仍不支持相对排名。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c2" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-exit", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-structure", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-exit", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-tier", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-data", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-tier", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-data", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-tier", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-data", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "缺少足够具体且口径一致的材料。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-billing", "status": "supported", "explanation": "对手称只计活跃订阅者；上游可能来自 MailerLite 自述，重复/归档口径未知。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-billing-active" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-billing", "status": "supported", "explanation": "按发送量计费，退订不直接增加费用；但存储上限按档位设置，退订是否计入上限未知。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-send-pricing" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-contact-caps" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-billing", "status": "opposed", "explanation": "四个家族称退订/非订阅联系人计费；旧资料称跨受众重复计费。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-contact-billing" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-duplicate" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-editor", "status": "supported", "explanation": "有三种编辑器的具体描述（2023）；旧 Growing Business 档 3 席位。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-editor" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-seats" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-editor", "status": "supported", "explanation": "有拖拽编辑器（2024）；但对手称 Standard 只有 1 个席位，多人维护时不利。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-editor" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-seats" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "preference_id": "newsletter-editor", "status": "supported", "explanation": "有两种构建器的具体描述（2023）。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-editor" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-structure", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "按活跃联系人档计费；发送频率低不降低费用，但也没有对手分析其低频适配性。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-billing-active" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-list-5000" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-structure", "status": "supported", "explanation": "按发送量计费，但存 5,000 联系人需 Starter 20,000 封档（据 Omnisend），不能按 5,000 封最低档计算。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-send-pricing" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-contact-caps" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-price-20k-starter" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-structure", "status": "opposed", "explanation": "按联系人（含退订）计费，低频发送不降低费用。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-contact-billing" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-exit", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "没有对手材料谈到导出或抑制状态保留。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-exit", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "对手只提到自动退订处理，未谈导出。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "preference_id": "low-exit", "status": "supported", "explanation": "Mailercloud 称可导出含同意状态的 CSV；单一来源。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-export" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-tier", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "多触发器仅 Power，分支所需档位未知。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-power-triggers" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-tier", "status": "conflicting", "explanation": "一说各套餐有分群，一说高级分群从 Professional 起；Starter 自动化另有 2,000 联系人上限。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-segment" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-adv-segment-pro" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-auto-cap" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-tier", "status": "supported", "explanation": "分支需 Standard，分群/标签在更低档已有，因此 Standard 同时具备两者。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-standard-multistep" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-segment-fields" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-data", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "无对手说明导出与集成的具体动作。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-data", "status": "unknown", "explanation": "对手只给出集成数量，不按数量排名；导出未谈。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "preference_id": "segment-data", "status": "supported", "explanation": "单一对手称有含同意状态的 CSV 导出。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-export" } ], "review_status": "original_assessment; not promoted to final ranking" } ], "comparisons": [ { "scenario_id": "newsletter", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "agreement_label": "partial_agreement", "agreement_scope": "仅比较原始轮次的场景处置状态；不代表所有功能、套餐或来源判断一致。", "rationale": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。", "original_dispositions": { "codex": "insufficient_evidence", "claude": "investigate_first" }, "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-welcome" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-monthly-send" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-billing-active" } ], "unresolved_conflict_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-mc-essentials" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-br-price" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-ml-price" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-mc-price" } ] }, { "scenario_id": "newsletter", "candidate_id": "brevo", "agreement_label": "agreement", "agreement_scope": "仅比较原始轮次的场景处置状态；不代表所有功能、套餐或来源判断一致。", "rationale": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。", "original_dispositions": { "codex": "investigate_first", "claude": "investigate_first" }, "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c1" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c2" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-welcome" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-auto-cap" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-no-daily-paid" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-standard-storage" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-price-10k-standard" } ], "unresolved_conflict_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-mc-essentials" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-br-price" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-ml-price" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-mc-price" } ] }, { "scenario_id": "newsletter", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "agreement_label": "agreement", "agreement_scope": "仅比较原始轮次的场景处置状态；不代表所有功能、套餐或来源判断一致。", "rationale": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。", "original_dispositions": { "codex": "investigate_first", "claude": "investigate_first" }, "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c3" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c4" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-standard-multistep" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-send-multiple" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-contact-billing" } ], "unresolved_conflict_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-mc-essentials" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-br-price" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-ml-price" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-mc-price" } ] }, { "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "agreement_label": "partial_agreement", "agreement_scope": "仅比较原始轮次的场景处置状态；不代表所有功能、套餐或来源判断一致。", "rationale": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。", "original_dispositions": { "codex": "insufficient_evidence", "claude": "investigate_first" }, "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-list-5000" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-monthly-send" } ], "unresolved_conflict_refs": [] }, { "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "candidate_id": "brevo", "agreement_label": "partial_agreement", "agreement_scope": "仅比较原始轮次的场景处置状态；不代表所有功能、套餐或来源判断一致。", "rationale": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。", "original_dispositions": { "codex": "investigate_first", "claude": "shortlisted" }, "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c1" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c2" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-contact-caps" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-price-20k-starter" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-no-daily-paid" } ], "unresolved_conflict_refs": [] }, { "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "agreement_label": "agreement", "agreement_scope": "仅比较原始轮次的场景处置状态；不代表所有功能、套餐或来源判断一致。", "rationale": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。", "original_dispositions": { "codex": "investigate_first", "claude": "investigate_first" }, "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c3" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c4" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-price-points" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-send-multiple" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-contact-billing" } ], "unresolved_conflict_refs": [] }, { "scenario_id": "segmentation", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "agreement_label": "partial_agreement", "agreement_scope": "仅比较原始轮次的场景处置状态；不代表所有功能、套餐或来源判断一致。", "rationale": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。", "original_dispositions": { "codex": "insufficient_evidence", "claude": "shortlisted" }, "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-segment-fields" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-branch" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-click-trigger" } ], "unresolved_conflict_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-br-price" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-br-seg-tier" } ] }, { "scenario_id": "segmentation", "candidate_id": "brevo", "agreement_label": "agreement", "agreement_scope": "仅比较原始轮次的场景处置状态；不代表所有功能、套餐或来源判断一致。", "rationale": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。", "original_dispositions": { "codex": "investigate_first", "claude": "investigate_first" }, "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c1" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c2" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-segment" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-ifelse" } ], "unresolved_conflict_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-br-price" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-br-seg-tier" } ] }, { "scenario_id": "segmentation", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "agreement_label": "partial_agreement", "agreement_scope": "仅比较原始轮次的场景处置状态；不代表所有功能、套餐或来源判断一致。", "rationale": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。", "original_dispositions": { "codex": "investigate_first", "claude": "shortlisted" }, "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c3" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c4" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-segment-fields" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-standard-multistep" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-behavior-triggers" } ], "unresolved_conflict_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-br-price" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "conflict_id": "cf-br-seg-tier" } ] } ], "scenario_decisions": [ { "scenario_id": "newsletter", "disposition": "investigate_first", "candidate_outcomes": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "disposition": "investigate_first", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-welcome" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-branch" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-segment-fields" } ], "reason": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "disposition": "investigate_first", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c1" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c2" } ], "reason": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "disposition": "investigate_first", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c3" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c4" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-behavior-triggers" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-segment-fields" } ], "reason": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。" } ], "comparative": { "status": "insufficient_basis", "preferred_candidate_id": null, "comparison_claim_ids": [], "reason": "没有同口径、同工作负载的实测或完整当前套餐依据，不指定相对赢家。" }, "options": [], "abstention_reason": "先验证文章中与自己需求有关的条件，再决定是否采用。", "verification_plan": [ { "question": "2000名许可订阅者每月4次群发加两步欢迎流程是否能在所需套餐完成？", "method": "用团队控制的测试数据建立最小流程，逐项操作硬约束，并核对席位、额度、导出与账单。", "required_user_data": { "opted_in_contacts": 2000, "campaigns_per_month": 4, "campaign_sends_per_month": 8000, "recipients_per_campaign": 2000, "campaign_delivery_window_days": 1, "new_subscribers_per_month": 100, "welcome_steps": 2, "automation_sends_additional": 200, "transactional_email": false }, "success_criterion": "支持两步顺序欢迎自动化；可行套餐支持一次2000人群发及月8200封总量", "failure_criterion": "任一必要操作不可用、额度不足或超出预算。", "status": "not_executed" } ] }, { "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "disposition": "investigate_first", "candidate_outcomes": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "disposition": "investigate_first", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-welcome" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-branch" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-segment-fields" } ], "reason": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "disposition": "investigate_first", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c1" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c2" } ], "reason": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "disposition": "investigate_first", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c3" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c4" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-behavior-triggers" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-segment-fields" } ], "reason": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。" } ], "comparative": { "status": "insufficient_basis", "preferred_candidate_id": null, "comparison_claim_ids": [], "reason": "没有同口径、同工作负载的实测或完整当前套餐依据，不指定相对赢家。" }, "options": [], "abstention_reason": "先验证文章中与自己需求有关的条件，再决定是否采用。", "verification_plan": [ { "question": "保留5000联系人，每月仅发送一次群发是否能在所需套餐完成？", "method": "用团队控制的测试数据建立最小流程，逐项操作硬约束，并核对席位、额度、导出与账单。", "required_user_data": { "opted_in_contacts": 5000, "campaigns_per_month": 1, "campaign_sends_per_month": 5000, "campaign_delivery_window_days": 1, "automation": false, "transactional_email": false }, "success_criterion": "可行套餐允许保存5000联系人；可在一个发送日内向5000人群发", "failure_criterion": "任一必要操作不可用、额度不足或超出预算。", "status": "not_executed" } ] }, { "scenario_id": "segmentation", "disposition": "investigate_first", "candidate_outcomes": [ { "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "disposition": "investigate_first", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-welcome" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-branch" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-segment-fields" } ], "reason": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。" }, { "candidate_id": "brevo", "disposition": "investigate_first", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c1" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c2" } ], "reason": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。" }, { "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "disposition": "investigate_first", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c3" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c4" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-behavior-triggers" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-segment-fields" } ], "reason": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。" } ], "comparative": { "status": "insufficient_basis", "preferred_candidate_id": null, "comparison_claim_ids": [], "reason": "没有同口径、同工作负载的实测或完整当前套餐依据，不指定相对赢家。" }, "options": [], "abstention_reason": "先验证文章中与自己需求有关的条件，再决定是否采用。", "verification_plan": [ { "question": "基于订阅属性与行为进行分群和分支自动化是否能在所需套餐完成？", "method": "用团队控制的测试数据建立最小流程，逐项操作硬约束，并核对席位、额度、导出与账单。", "required_user_data": { "opted_in_contacts": 2000, "campaign_sends_per_month": 8000, "automation_sends_additional": 1000, "branch_conditions": [ "subscriber attribute", "click event" ], "required_export": "contacts and suppression state", "transactional_email": false }, "success_criterion": "支持按联系人属性进行分群；支持行为触发的分支自动化", "failure_criterion": "任一必要操作不可用、额度不足或超出预算。", "status": "not_executed" } ] } ], "conflicts": [ { "id": "cf-mc-essentials", "affected_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter" ], "description": "GetResponse（2025-11）与 Moosend（2024）称 Essentials 只有单步自动化；Omnisend（2026-09）称升级到 Standard 前流程最多 4 步。", "scope_comparison": "同一产品与套餐，日期不同；Omnisend 未明确点名 Essentials。", "disposition": "unresolved", "rationale": "较新日期本身不能解决冲突。它只影响两步欢迎流程可用的最低档，不影响 Standard 可行的判断。", "required_verification": "用试用账户在 Essentials 档尝试建立两步欢迎流程。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-essentials-single" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-essentials-4step" } ], "review_status": "original_conflict_retained; not independently resolved" }, { "id": "cf-br-contacts", "affected_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency" ], "description": "Moosend（2024）称所有套餐联系人不限；Omnisend（2026）与 MailerLite 称存在按档位的联系人上限。", "scope_comparison": "MailerLite 页面明确称 Brevo 于 2025 年末重构定价、加入联系人上限，两者属于不同套餐版本。", "disposition": "resolved_scope_difference", "rationale": "不是只凭日期较新：另有对手说明了套餐版本变化，Moosend 描述的是重构前的套餐。", "required_verification": "在 Brevo 定价页核对每个发送档对应的联系人上限。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-unlimited-2024" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-contact-caps" } ], "review_status": "original_conflict_retained; not independently resolved" }, { "id": "cf-br-price", "affected_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "segmentation" ], "description": "Standard 10,000 封/月：$35（Omnisend 定价文、MailerLite）与 $18（Omnisend 对比文）/ $16 起（Mailchimp）不一致。", "scope_comparison": "同一套餐，发送档对应可能写错；Omnisend 定价文称 $18 对应 5,000 封。", "disposition": "unresolved", "rationale": "无法从准入来源确定哪一个数字正确。", "required_verification": "在定价页选择 Standard、10,000 封、月付，记录美元价格。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-price-10k-standard" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-standard-10k-18" } ], "review_status": "original_conflict_retained; not independently resolved" }, { "id": "cf-ml-free", "affected_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter", "low-frequency" ], "description": "MailerLite 免费版：250/2,500（EmailOctopus、Omnisend 2026）与 500 订阅者（Mailchimp、Mailercloud）不一致。", "scope_comparison": "EmailOctopus 明确记录了免费版调整，属于不同版本。", "disposition": "resolved_scope_difference", "rationale": "有对手记录版本变化；免费版本来也不能承载本期场景，不影响决策。", "required_verification": "无需，除非改为评估免费版。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-free-250" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-free-500" } ], "review_status": "original_conflict_retained; not independently resolved" }, { "id": "cf-ml-price", "affected_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter" ], "description": "MailerLite 2,500 订阅者档价格 $17 与 $20 不一致。", "scope_comparison": "套餐未注明，日期不同，均可能早于 2026 年调价。", "disposition": "unresolved", "rationale": "无法判断哪一个适用于当前 Comfort 档。", "required_verification": "在定价页核对 Comfort 2,500 档的月付价格。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-price-2500-17" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-price-2500-20" } ], "review_status": "original_conflict_retained; not independently resolved" }, { "id": "cf-mc-price", "affected_scenario_ids": [ "newsletter" ], "description": "Mailchimp 2,500 联系人档价格 $60（MailerLite）与 $45（Mailercloud）不一致。", "scope_comparison": "套餐可能不同（Standard 与未注明）。", "disposition": "unresolved", "rationale": "套餐口径不明。", "required_verification": "在定价页核对 Essentials/Standard 2,500 档价格。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-price-points" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-price-2500-45" } ], "review_status": "original_conflict_retained; not independently resolved" }, { "id": "cf-br-seg-tier", "affected_scenario_ids": [ "segmentation" ], "description": "一说各套餐都有分群，一说高级分群从 Professional 起。", "scope_comparison": "'advanced' 的范围未定义，可能是基础与高级分群之分。", "disposition": "unresolved", "rationale": "不能确定本场景所需的属性 + 点击条件属于哪一类。", "required_verification": "在 Starter/Standard 试用中创建“属性 + 点击”组合分群。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "evidence_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-segment" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-br-adv-segment-pro" } ], "review_status": "original_conflict_retained; not independently resolved" } ], "coverage_gaps": [ { "id": "g-mailerlite-newsletter", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "question": "核实 支持两步顺序欢迎自动化；可行套餐支持一次2000人群发及月8200封总量", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-brevo-newsletter", "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "question": "核实 支持两步顺序欢迎自动化；可行套餐支持一次2000人群发及月8200封总量", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-mailchimp-newsletter", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "question": "核实 支持两步顺序欢迎自动化；可行套餐支持一次2000人群发及月8200封总量", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-mailerlite-low-frequency", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "question": "核实 可行套餐允许保存5000联系人；可在一个发送日内向5000人群发", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-brevo-low-frequency", "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "question": "核实 可行套餐允许保存5000联系人；可在一个发送日内向5000人群发", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-mailchimp-low-frequency", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "question": "核实 可行套餐允许保存5000联系人；可在一个发送日内向5000人群发", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-mailerlite-segmentation", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "question": "核实 支持按联系人属性进行分群；支持行为触发的分支自动化", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-brevo-segmentation", "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "question": "核实 支持按联系人属性进行分群；支持行为触发的分支自动化", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-mailchimp-segmentation", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "question": "核实 支持按联系人属性进行分群；支持行为触发的分支自动化", "why_missing": "公开对手材料未完整覆盖具体使用场景。", "decision_impact": "只保留调查方向，未覆盖的要求不视为已满足。", "next_action": "在试用环境按冻结工作量完成一次端到端操作并保存结果。", "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-ml-daily", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": null, "question": "MailerLite Comfort/Power 付费档是否有日发送上限、速率限制或新账户审核？", "why_missing": "已读的对手材料都没有提到；检索到的相关页面多为 MailerLite 自述，不准入。", "decision_impact": "导致 newsletter-send 与 low-send 为 unknown，候选只能列为 investigate_first。", "next_action": "查阅 MailerLite 文档或试用账户（在本期政策之外核实）。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-mc-daily", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": null, "question": "Mailchimp 付费档是否有日发送上限？", "why_missing": "对手只谈到免费版的日上限；检索到的是 Mailchimp 自述或来源不明的页面。", "decision_impact": "newsletter-send 与 low-send 为 unknown。", "next_action": "查阅 Mailchimp 文档或试用账户。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-br-tier-map", "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": null, "question": "Brevo 各发送档对应的联系人上限是多少？Standard 是否确实没有日上限？", "why_missing": "对手只列出 500/1,500/2,500/500,000 这几个上限，没有完整的逐档对应。", "decision_impact": "影响可行档位与价格；是 Brevo 入选的前提条件。", "next_action": "在定价页核对。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-ml-branch-tier", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "segmentation", "question": "条件分支（含点击条件）在 Comfort 档是否可用？", "why_missing": "对手只说多触发器仅 Power，没有说明条件分支的档位。", "decision_impact": "影响档位与成本。", "next_action": "试用 Comfort 档。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-click-branch", "candidate_id": null, "scenario_id": "segmentation", "question": "三者能否按“邮件点击”事件分支？", "why_missing": "对手描述的是分支或行为触发，没有逐一确认点击分支。", "decision_impact": "是 segmentation 场景的核心工作流，目前只有 limited 支持。", "next_action": "用测试邮箱做分支验证。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-ml-export", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "question": "能否导出联系人及退订/抑制状态？", "why_missing": "没有对手材料提到。", "decision_impact": "影响 low-exit/segment-data 偏好。", "next_action": "试用导出。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-br-export", "candidate_id": "brevo", "scenario_id": "low-frequency", "question": "能否导出联系人及退订/抑制状态？", "why_missing": "对手只提到自动退订处理。", "decision_impact": "影响 low-exit/segment-data 偏好。", "next_action": "试用导出。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-billing-detail", "candidate_id": null, "scenario_id": "newsletter", "question": "归档联系人、跨群组重复联系人在 MailerLite 与 Brevo 存储上限中如何计算？", "why_missing": "对手没有谈到。", "decision_impact": "影响计费口径偏好与成本。", "next_action": "查阅各自计费说明。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-brevo-pages", "candidate_id": null, "scenario_id": null, "question": "Brevo 自己发布的对比页如何描述 MailerLite 与 Mailchimp？", "why_missing": "3 个 Brevo 页面的正文都无法读取（被截断或只取回标题）。", "decision_impact": "少了一个评价 MailerLite/Mailchimp 的对手家族。", "next_action": "下一轮用其他抓取方式重试。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-mc-essentials", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "scenario_id": "newsletter", "question": "Essentials 能否做两步欢迎流程？", "why_missing": "对手说法冲突。", "decision_impact": "影响最低可行档与成本。", "next_action": "试用 Essentials。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-costs-tax", "candidate_id": null, "scenario_id": null, "question": "税费、年付折扣、超额规则如何？", "why_missing": "对手材料大多没有说明。", "decision_impact": "所有成本都是 incomplete 或 conflicting。", "next_action": "核对定价页。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-deliverability", "candidate_id": null, "scenario_id": null, "question": "进箱率、送达率与合规（同意记录、GDPR）", "why_missing": "按协议不能用竞品营销说法证明，本期未评估。", "decision_impact": "不影响本期的适配判断，但也没有得到任何保证。", "next_action": "用受控小样本测试流程；进箱表现需要独立的方法评估。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" }, { "id": "g-fetch-verbatim", "candidate_id": null, "scenario_id": null, "question": "提取内容是否为逐字原文？", "why_missing": "WebFetch 返回的是模型处理后的提取，无法保证逐字准确。", "decision_impact": "所有命题都可能有转述误差；摘录置 null。", "next_action": "发布前由人工逐页核对定位段落。", "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing" } ], "verification_plan": [ { "question": "2000名许可订阅者每月4次群发加两步欢迎流程是否能在所需套餐完成？", "method": "用团队控制的测试数据建立最小流程，逐项操作硬约束，并核对席位、额度、导出与账单。", "required_user_data": { "opted_in_contacts": 2000, "campaigns_per_month": 4, "campaign_sends_per_month": 8000, "recipients_per_campaign": 2000, "campaign_delivery_window_days": 1, "new_subscribers_per_month": 100, "welcome_steps": 2, "automation_sends_additional": 200, "transactional_email": false }, "success_criterion": "支持两步顺序欢迎自动化；可行套餐支持一次2000人群发及月8200封总量", "failure_criterion": "任一必要操作不可用、额度不足或超出预算。", "status": "not_executed" }, { "question": "保留5000联系人，每月仅发送一次群发是否能在所需套餐完成？", "method": "用团队控制的测试数据建立最小流程，逐项操作硬约束，并核对席位、额度、导出与账单。", "required_user_data": { "opted_in_contacts": 5000, "campaigns_per_month": 1, "campaign_sends_per_month": 5000, "campaign_delivery_window_days": 1, "automation": false, "transactional_email": false }, "success_criterion": "可行套餐允许保存5000联系人；可在一个发送日内向5000人群发", "failure_criterion": "任一必要操作不可用、额度不足或超出预算。", "status": "not_executed" }, { "question": "基于订阅属性与行为进行分群和分支自动化是否能在所需套餐完成？", "method": "用团队控制的测试数据建立最小流程，逐项操作硬约束，并核对席位、额度、导出与账单。", "required_user_data": { "opted_in_contacts": 2000, "campaign_sends_per_month": 8000, "automation_sends_additional": 1000, "branch_conditions": [ "subscriber attribute", "click event" ], "required_export": "contacts and suppression state", "transactional_email": false }, "success_criterion": "支持按联系人属性进行分群；支持行为触发的分支自动化", "failure_criterion": "任一必要操作不可用、额度不足或超出预算。", "status": "not_executed" } ], "entries": [ { "product": "MailerLite", "candidate_id": "mailerlite", "best_for": "newsletter、欢迎序列及基础分群。", "rationale": "Mailercloud 描述了 MailerLite 的欢迎序列、条件分支和自定义字段筛选，可以先用两封欢迎邮件验证搭建与维护是否顺手。", "caveat": "先确认当前套餐能覆盖 2,000 人同日群发和每月 8,200 封；不要直接套用旧免费额度或旧套餐价格。", "status": "先核实额度", "evidence_strength": "limited", "evidence": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-welcome" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-branch" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-segment-fields" } ], "source_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "source_id": "s20", "url": "https://www.mailercloud.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp", "title": "MailerLite vs Mailchimp (2026): 14-Round Comparison", "publisher": "Mailercloud" } ] }, { "product": "Brevo", "candidate_id": "brevo", "best_for": "联系人较多、发送频率较低，想比较发送量计费的团队。", "rationale": "MailerLite 描述了 Brevo 按发送量计费的方式。低频发送时值得单独算一遍，但还要同时看联系人容量。", "caveat": "免费档每日 300 封的限制无法覆盖同日 2,000 人群发。选择付费档时，把联系人上限、日发送量和自动化范围一起确认。", "status": "先算实际工作量", "evidence_strength": "limited", "evidence": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c1" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c2" } ], "source_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "source_id": "s1", "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/brevo-alternative", "title": "MailerLite vs Brevo", "publisher": "MailerLite" } ] }, { "product": "Mailchimp", "candidate_id": "mailchimp", "best_for": "需要电商行为触发、多步分支和更细分群的营销流程。", "rationale": "Mailercloud 描述了 Mailchimp 的多步分支、行为触发和自定义字段组合分群，适合先搭一个实际客户旅程验证。", "caveat": "自动化能力随套餐变化；联系人账单还可能包含退订和非订阅联系人。先整理名单，再确认流程档位和发送额度。", "status": "先核实自动化档位", "evidence_strength": "limited", "evidence": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c3" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c4" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-behavior-triggers" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-segment-fields" } ], "source_refs": [ { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "source_id": "s2", "url": "https://www.mailerlite.com/mailchimp-alternative", "title": "MailerLite vs Mailchimp", "publisher": "MailerLite" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "source_id": "s20", "url": "https://www.mailercloud.com/blog/mailerlite-vs-mailchimp", "title": "MailerLite vs Mailchimp (2026): 14-Round Comparison", "publisher": "Mailercloud" } ] } ] }, "review_notes": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": null, "issue": "原始输出中的多来源一致、套餐通过或价格估算不可直接继承。", "correction": "新增欢迎流程和分群线索；同日发送、点击事件分支和具体套餐仍需核实。 所有发布建议为待试用；采用的功能线索统一为 limited。", "supporting_refs": [ { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-welcome" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-branch" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-ml-segment-fields" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c1" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c2" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c3" }, { "run_id": "codex-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c4" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-behavior-triggers" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-segment-fields" } ], "effect_on_decision": "完整场景统一 investigate_first，不计算平均价格或评分。" }, { "run_id": "claude-v2-2026-09-28-email-marketing", "claim_id": "c-mc-free-daily", "issue": "免费版月发送量与联系人上限可能混淆。", "correction": "不采用该命题的月发送数字；文章只保留独立复读过的付费功能线索。Mailercloud 的定价总表明确归因目标厂商，亦未用于定价结论。", "supporting_refs": [], "effect_on_decision": "不发布免费额度推算或确定套餐价格。" } ], "edition": "v2-2026-09-28", "prompt_version": "2.0.0", "research_cutoff": "2026-09-27T23:16:52.790325+00:00", "status": "partial", "source_policy": "competitor-only" }